| Purity1850-08-11 · #8178 | Death, which must ever have existed as a form of dissolution, a passing from one state to another, became a curse; the sting of death was sin—unchanged in itself, it changed in man. paragraph 20, in the edition on www.gutenberg.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment. the printed paragraph around the quote · printed editionthis subject we learn to understand two things. Hence we understand the Fall. When man fell, the world fell with him. All creation received a shock. Thorns, briars, and thistles, sprang up. They were there before, but to the now restless and impatient hands of men they became obstacles and weeds. Death, which must ever have existed as a form of dissolution, a passing from one state to another, became a curse; the sting of death was sin—unchanged in itself, it changed in man. A dark, heavy cloud, rested on it—the shadow of his own guilty heart.
| 2 teachings Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: that Adam was created mortal and would have died apart from sin“Canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Caelestius — eight canons anathematising, in turn: that Adam was created mortal and would have died apart from sin; that infants are not baptised for the remission of original sin; that grace remits past sins only and does not assist against future ones; that grace only illuminates the understanding without also enabling the doing; that grace makes obedience easier rather than possible; that 'if we say we have no sin we deceive ourselves' is said only out of humility; that the saints say 'forgive us our trespasses' only on others' behalf; and that they say it without meaning it of themselves.” Words as recorded in Council of Carthage, canon 109, 418-05-01 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116) the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: the claim heldRobertson asserts this in his own expository voice, under his own heading "Hence we understand the Fall," with no scripture match and no quoted source. The sentence says death "must ever have existed" and was "unchanged in itself" by the Fall — only its meaning for man changed, from natural passage to curse — which is precisely Carthage's condemned claim that bodily death would have come by natural necessity rather than through sin. No mainstream tradition teaches that death was unchanged in itself by the Fall while still holding that Adam would not have died apart from sin; the parallel sentence about thorns ("They were there before") confirms he means the thing itself pre-existed and only man's relation to it altered. Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: the claim heldThe sentence is the preacher's own expository claim about the Fall, not scripture read aloud or a view reported to be answered — it sits in his own argument ("Hence we understand the Fall"), parallel to his claim that thorns and briars "were there before" and only became weeds to fallen man. Applied to death, he says the same: death as dissolution "must ever have existed," and the Fall changed only man's relation to it ("unchanged in itself, it changed in man"), which is precisely Carthage canon 109's target — death by natural necessity rather than as the wage of Adam's sin. No mainstream tradition that holds Carthage teaches that human death would have occurred anyway and that sin merely altered its subjective character; describing it as "a passing from one state to another" is the Pelagian transition-out-of-the-body account the canon names. Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: the claim heldThe sentence comes in the preacher's own expository section ("Hence we understand the Fall"), not from a read text (the scripture check found no match) and not as a quoted or answered view — the parallel with thorns and briars that "were there before" is his own construction. In his own voice he says death "must ever have existed" as dissolution and was "unchanged in itself," sin altering only its character as curse, which is precisely Carthage canon 109's target: that man would have passed out of the body by natural necessity rather than through sin. No mainstream tradition — Catholic, Reformed or Eastern — teaches that bodily death belonged to man's created condition apart from sin, so the orthodox-reading escape is not available here. Scripture: not a Bible quotation Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: Mortality is natural to human beings and was not introduced by the fall“Mortality is natural to human beings and was not introduced by the fall — Adam was created mortal, and immortality is a gift, not a property.” Words as recorded in The Racovian Catechism (Catechesis ecclesiarum quae in Regno Poloniae ... affirmant), Of the knowledge of God, on the fall and on free will (Rees, 1818), 1605-1609 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: the claim heldUnder the heading "Hence we understand the Fall" the preacher is teaching in his own voice, not reading or quoting scripture (the scripture check found no match), and he states doctrinally that death "must ever have existed as a form of dissolution" and was "unchanged in itself," the fall altering only man's relation to it — exactly the claim that bodily mortality was not introduced by the fall. His surrounding argument confirms this is deliberate, not incidental: thorns and briars likewise "were there before" and only became obstacles to fallen man, so the whole external order, death included, is held to be unchanged by the fall. No mainstream tradition teaches that human death pre-existed and would have existed apart from sin; the opposite is the standard Western position (Carthage 418, Trent V), so no orthodox reading rescues the sentence. Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: the claim heldThe sentence comes in the preacher's own doctrinal exposition ("Hence we understand the Fall"), not from a text read aloud or a view voiced to be answered; the only scriptural echo, "the sting of death was sin," is folded into his own claim. He states that death "must ever have existed" as dissolution and that the fall left it "unchanged in itself," altering only man's relation to it — which is precisely the claim that mortality belongs to human nature and was not introduced by the fall, parallel to the thorns which "were there before." The available orthodox alternatives do not cover it: Thomism holds immortality was a lost gift but that unfallen Adam would not in fact have died, whereas this sermon asserts death would have existed regardless. Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: the claim heldThe sentence is the preacher's own expository claim in the section "Hence we understand the Fall" — not a text read aloud (the scripture check found no match) and not a view voiced to be answered; the only quoted words are the clause from 1 Cor 15:56, which he uses as support for his own assertion. Set in parallel with "Thorns, briars, and thistles... were there before," the claim that death "must ever have existed" and was "unchanged in itself" says directly that human death pre-existed and was not introduced by the fall, with the fall adding only its character as curse — which is the proposition's substance. No mainstream tradition can teach this sentence while denying that mortality preceded the fall: Aquinas's "immortality is a gift" is compatible with natural corruptibility, but holds that actual death came by the loss of that gift, which is precisely what "must ever have existed" denies. Scripture: not a Bible quotation
| Published the claim held on all 3 challenges read in the whole sermon |