All churches › Frederick W. Robertson › Teachings the church historically rejected
Frederick W. Robertson
What do the ▸ links mean?
Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →
1 published passage in 1 sermon, matching 2 teachings · 16 withdrawn, of 17 flagged in 21 sermons read
Sermons: 21 read whole · 21 read in their reframes
Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.
| Sermon | What was said | Matches | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purity1850-08-11 · #8178 |
| 2 teachings
| Published the claim held on all 3 challenges read in the whole sermon |
Show the 16 withdrawn passages
Passages 11–16 of 16
Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.
| Sermon | What was said | Matches | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Absolution1850-06-02 · #8173 |
| Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: Grace is real and necessary, but it is understood as gift preceding and surrounding the act rather than as an…“Grace is real and necessary, but it is understood as gift preceding and surrounding the act rather than as an interior cause of it: the gift of a free nature, the law, the teaching and example of Christ, the forgiveness of past sins in baptism.” Words as recorded in Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116), Canons 111, 112, 113, 418 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116) | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the reframes alone the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted line is part of a lament, not a claim: "And this is what we have forgotten: we have not yet learned to trust the power of redeeming love; we do not believe in the omnipotence of grace..." Robertson is rebuking his hearers for failing to believe in grace's omnipotence — he is urging a stronger, not weaker, doctrine of grace's efficacy. The sentence therefore says the opposite of the Pelagian proposition that grace is merely an external gift surrounding the act rather than an interior cause of it, and nothing in it touches free nature, law, example or baptismal remission as substitutes for inward grace. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe cited sentence is a reproach, not a Pelagian claim: Robertson is faulting his hearers ("this is what we have forgotten... we do not believe in the omnipotence of grace") for failing to trust grace's power. Read in its own sentence, it asserts that grace IS omnipotent and that redeeming love should be trusted — the opposite of treating grace as a merely external gift rather than an inward cause. The paired clause about "an appeal to the better parts... of human nature" describes Christ's absolving method over against Pharisaic law-fear, and carries nothing about grace being external to the act; the proposition's specific content (grace as gift surrounding but not interiorly causing the good act) is simply not in the quote. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is a lament, not an assertion of the Pelagian position: Robertson's complaint is that "we do not believe in the omnipotence of grace" — i.e. he is reproaching his hearers for failing to credit grace's power, and thereby affirming it. Far from treating grace as merely an external gift surrounding the act, he insists on "the power of redeeming love" and calls salvation "not an offer, but a Gift... free as the air we breathe," which is the opposite of the condemned Carthaginian proposition. The evidence cannot carry the claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| Absolution1850-06-02 · #8173 |
| Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice“Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice.” Words as recorded in Fausto Sozzini, De Jesu Christo Servatore, De Jesu Christo Servatore, parts I-III, 1594 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the reframes alone the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence — that "the absolving power is the central secret of the Gospel" — is a claim about where the emphasis of the Gospel lies and about the declarative power of forgiveness entrusted to the Church; it says nothing at all about whether Christ saves by satisfying divine justice. The Socinian proposition is a specific denial of satisfaction/atonement, and asserting that forgiveness is central does not deny the ground on which forgiveness rests. Robertson's nearby polemic is against a caricature ("God as an incensed judge" who "sells forgiveness"), not against the doctrine of satisfaction as such, and in any case that is not the sentence put forward as evidence. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence says only that the absolving power — the declaration of God's forgiveness — is central to the Gospel; it says nothing about the ground of that forgiveness, and so does not deny that Christ saves by satisfying divine justice. The sermon's subject throughout is who may declare pardon (God, Christ as Son of Man, the Church, man as man), not the mechanism of atonement, and the surrounding sentences ("Salvation is unconditional; not an offer, but a Gift") are about the freeness of the gift, which mainstream Protestant teaching holds alongside satisfaction. A proposition as specific as Sozzini's denial of satisfaction cannot be carried by this sentence. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence claims that the absolving power — the authoritative declaration of God's forgiveness — is the heart of the Gospel. That is a claim about where the Gospel's centre of gravity and pastoral force lie; it says nothing at all about the ground of atonement, and is silent on whether Christ's death satisfied divine justice. Many wholly orthodox preachers make forgiveness the "central secret" of the Gospel while holding satisfaction firmly, so the sentence cannot bear the Socinian denial placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| Absolution1850-06-02 · #8173 |
| Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: forgiveness and payment are mutually exclusive“Socinus's argument in De Jesu Christo Servatore is that forgiveness and payment are mutually exclusive — a debt paid is not a debt forgiven — that guilt and punishment are not transferable between persons, that an eternal penalty cannot be discharged by a temporary death, and that God, being free, may simply forgive.” Words as recorded in Fausto Sozzini, De Jesu Christo Servatore, De Jesu Christo Servatore, parts I-III, 1594 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the reframes alone the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawn"God loves without money and without price" echoes Isaiah 55:1 and, in context ("Salvation is unconditional; not an offer, but a Gift; not clogged with conditions"), asserts that pardon costs the sinner nothing — the free-grace commonplace of every Protestant tradition, and here aimed at priestly penances and "methods of appeasing him" by which men would buy forgiveness. It says nothing about whether Christ's satisfaction was made, and so does not carry Socinus's sharpened claim that a debt paid cannot be a debt forgiven. The condemned proposition concerns the logical incompatibility of payment and pardon; this sentence concerns the freeness of pardon to its recipient, which mainstream orthodoxy teaches while affirming the atonement. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe Socinian proposition is a claim about the logic of atonement — that a debt paid cannot be a debt forgiven, so satisfaction is incompatible with pardon. The quoted sentences say nothing about satisfaction or Christ's death; in context ("Salvation is unconditional; not an offer, but a Gift") they assert only that God's welcome of the penitent is gratuitous and costs the sinner nothing, which is the ordinary free-grace sense of Isaiah 55:1 and Luke 15 preached across mainstream traditions. Robertson's named target here is the "Scribe" who makes pardon depend on penances and conditions supplied by the sinner, not the doctrine that Christ paid a price. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe Socinian proposition is that a debt paid cannot be a debt forgiven — a denial that Christ's satisfaction is compatible with, or needed for, pardon. Robertson's sentence, echoing Isaiah 55:1 ("without money and without price") and the parable of the prodigal, says only that God's pardon is free to the sinner and not bought by the sinner's penances or merit; in context he is attacking "Protestant Scribes" who think God "is willing to sell forgiveness" to the penitent, not the doctrine of atonement. Free grace on the sinner's side is ordinary teaching across traditions and says nothing about whether satisfaction was made by Christ, so the quote does not carry the claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Dispensation of the Spirit1850-05-19 · #8171 |
| Eutychianism, rejected at the Home Synod of Constantinople, 448: the humanity is absorbed, altered or otherwise not preserved intact in the union, so that Christ is not fully and…“The condemned implication drawn by his examiners is that the humanity is absorbed, altered or otherwise not preserved intact in the union, so that Christ is not fully and permanently one of us.” Words as recorded in The Definition of Faith and canons of the Council of Chalcedon, Definition of Faith, 451 · Condemned by a council · Home Synod (synodos endemousa) of Constantinople under Archbishop Flavian, 448 · source: The Definition of Faith and canons of the Council of Chalcedon | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence is Robertson's gloss on 1 Corinthians 15:28, which he has just quoted, and it concerns the withdrawal of Christ's bodily, external mode of presence and authority in the dispensation of the Spirit ("the Son to disappear as an outward authority, in order that he might re-appear as an inward principle of life"), not the absorption or alteration of the human nature in the hypostatic union. He elsewhere in the same sermon affirms "perfect Humanity" and a "Divine Humanity" in Christ. The eschatological/Ascension theme is ordinary teaching about knowing Christ no longer "after the flesh" (2 Cor 5:16), and carries no Eutychian claim about the two natures. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is Robertson's own gloss on 1 Cor 15:28 and 2 Cor 5:16, and the "union" he has in view is the union of God with believers by the indwelling Spirit, not the union of the two natures in Christ that the Eutychian proposition concerns. His own immediately following words fix the sense — "It was necessary for the Son to disappear as an outward authority, in order that he might re-appear as an inward principle of life" — i.e. a change in the mode of Christ's presence after the Ascension, which is ordinary teaching about Pentecost, not the absorption or alteration of Christ's human nature. The quote therefore does not carry the claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnRobertson speaks this sentence in his own voice, but the "union" he means is not the union of natures in Christ — it is the Spirit's indwelling of believers, as his framing shows: the sentence glosses "that God may be all in all" and "henceforth know we Him no more" after the flesh, and he explains it immediately as the Son ceasing to be "an outward authority" so as to "re-appear as an inward principle of life... a Christ within us." What disappears is the external, visible mode of revelation at the Ascension, which is standard teaching on why the Spirit was not given until Jesus was glorified. He nowhere claims Christ's humanity is absorbed or not preserved in the incarnational union, which is what the Home Synod of 448 condemned. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Dispensation of the Spirit1850-05-19 · #8171 |
| Sabellianism, rejected by a presbytery at Smyrna, c. 200: the one God plays three parts in succession“In the Sabellian form as later writers report it, the one God plays three parts in succession.” Words as recorded in The creed and canons of the First Council of Constantinople, Canon 1, 381 · Condemned by a church ruling · A presbytery at Smyrna, c. 200 · source: The creed and canons of the First Council of Constantinople | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence concerns the manner of Christ's presence — the ascension of the incarnate Son preceding Pentecost, so that he is known no longer as an external voice but as "a Christ within us, the hope of glory" (Col. 1:27) — which is ordinary Christian teaching on ascension, indwelling and Paul's "though we have known Christ after the flesh, yet henceforth know we him no more." Modalism is the claim that there are no distinct persons, only one God successively wearing three masks; the sermon's framework of three dispensations of revelation (Father in creation, Son in the incarnate Word, Spirit within) is the economy of revelation, a scheme taught by mainstream writers from Gregory Nazianzen onward, and the sermon keeps Son and Spirit distinct throughout. The evidence therefore does not carry the condemned proposition, since a mainstream reading of this sentence teaches nothing modalist. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about the Son's change of mode of presence after the Ascension — withdrawn as an external authoritative voice, given back as the indwelling "Christ within us, the hope of glory" — which is a paraphrase of John 16:7 and Colossians 1:27 and is taught across mainstream traditions without any denial of the distinction of persons. It says nothing about the one God successively playing three parts; Robertson's sentence concerns the Son alone and he keeps Father, Son and Spirit as distinct agents throughout. Whatever one makes of his broader scheme of three dispensations, this particular quote does not carry the Sabellian claim that was put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about the mode of Christ's presence — his bodily, external presence withdrawn at the Ascension so that he may indwell believers by the Spirit — which is ordinary teaching drawn from John 16:7 ("it is expedient for you that I go away") and Colossians 1:27 ("Christ in you, the hope of glory"), and the preacher immediately glosses it that way. It says nothing about the one God successively assuming the roles of Father, Son and Spirit; the Son does not cease to be or become another person, he changes how he is present. The sermon's framing of three dispensations is an economic account of revelation, which mainstream traditions teach without any Sabellian collapse of the persons. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Tongue1850-04-28 · #8169 |
| Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: Grace is real and necessary, but it is understood as gift preceding and surrounding the act rather than as an…“Grace is real and necessary, but it is understood as gift preceding and surrounding the act rather than as an interior cause of it: the gift of a free nature, the law, the teaching and example of Christ, the forgiveness of past sins in baptism.” Words as recorded in Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116), Canons 111, 112, 113, 418 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116) | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnRobertson is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence belongs to an argument that evil is unnatural and that redemption restores rather than replaces humanity — the familiar orthodox claim that grace perfects nature and does not destroy it. He immediately adds "Christianity is the regeneration of our whole nature, not the destruction of one atom of it," which affirms an inward renewing work rather than reducing grace to external teaching, law and example as Carthage's canons describe. The denial of "an infusion of something new into Humanity" is directed against the idea that Christ adds something alien to human nature, not against grace as the interior cause of good acts, so the Pelagian proposition cannot safely be put in his mouth. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnRobertson is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence is doing different work than the proposition requires. His denial of "an infusion of something new into Humanity" is a denial that redemption adds something alien to human nature — the restoration-of-nature theme that is mainstream in Irenaean recapitulation and in the Western maxim that grace does not destroy but perfects nature. In the very next breath he calls Christianity "the regeneration of our whole nature," which is an interior work and the opposite of the Pelagian reduction of grace to external gift (law, teaching, example, baptismal remission). The sermon's subject is the unnaturalness of slander, not the mechanism of grace, and nothing here confines grace to what precedes or surrounds the act. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnRobertson does speak in his own voice here, but the sentence is doing different work than the classification supposes: in context he is defining evil as unnatural and arguing that redemption restores the created nature rather than replacing it — "Christianity is the regeneration of our whole nature, not the destruction of one atom of it." That grace heals and perfects nature rather than adding an alien substance is ordinary mainstream teaching (Aquinas's gratia non tollit naturam; the Eastern and Anglican language of restoring the image), and his own appeal to "regeneration" and to "the co-operation of a Divine spirit" is an interior work, not Pelagius's reduction of grace to free nature, law, example and baptismal remission. "Not an infusion of something new" denies a novelty added to humanity, not an inward operation of grace. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
Withdrawn passages, 10 to a page, each with its challenges in full: 1–10 · 11–16
How these were counted
The part of each printed sermon read: teaching 21 — each part named with how many printed sermons it was read in.
- printed sermons
- 21
- window
- every printed sermon held here
- read by
- an AI model; details in About the study
We checked the sermons of Frederick W. Robertson against 115 rejected teachings, reading 21 whole sermons and the reframes of 21 sermons.
17 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.
The withdrawn passages come from 8 of the 21 sermons checked.
Read whole. 21 of the 21 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 15 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Read in their reframes. 21 of the 21 sermons in the basis above were read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 4 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.