All churches › Frederick W. Robertson › Teachings the church historically rejected
Frederick W. Robertson
What do the ▸ links mean?
Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →
1 published passage in 1 sermon, matching 2 teachings · 16 withdrawn, of 17 flagged in 21 sermons read
Sermons: 21 read whole · 21 read in their reframes
Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.
| Sermon | What was said | Matches | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purity1850-08-11 · #8178 |
| 2 teachings
| Published the claim held on all 3 challenges read in the whole sermon |
Show the 16 withdrawn passages
Passages 1–10 of 16
Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.
| Sermon | What was said | Matches | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| John's Rebuke of Herod1853-05-15 · #8189 |
| Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: the claim that the beginning of faith and the very desire to believe belong to us by nature and not…“Canon 5 anathematises the claim that the beginning of faith and the very desire to believe belong to us by nature and not by a gift of grace; canon 6 the claim that God has mercy when, apart from his grace, we believe, will, desire, strive, labour, pray, watch, study, seek, ask or knock; canon 7 the claim that we can make any right choice relating to salvation, or assent to the preaching of the gospel, by natural powers without the illumination of the Holy Spirit; canon 4 the claim that God awaits our will to be cleansed rather than causing that will.” Words as recorded in Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), canon 5, 529-07-03 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe preacher is asserting in his own voice that humans have an innate longing to reverence and worship something greater than themselves, and that Christ alone satisfies it — a commonplace of mainstream teaching (Augustine's restless heart, Calvin's semen religionis) that describes a natural capacity and need, not the beginning of saving faith. Orange's canon 5 condemns the narrower claim that the initium fidei and the desiderium credendi are ours by nature rather than by a gift of grace; a natural hunger that Christ must answer is not the same as a natural ability to begin believing, and the sermon says nothing about the origin of faith or the role of grace here. The classification reads a sharpened Semi-Pelagian thesis into a sentence that an orthodox tradition teaches without it. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnRobertson is describing an anthropological fact — that the human heart craves a guide and an object of reverence — and saying Christ alone satisfies it. He says nothing about the origin of the beginning of faith (the initium fidei) or the desire to believe, which is what Orange canon 5 condemns locating in nature rather than grace. A restless natural longing answered only by Christ is Augustine's own "our heart is restless until it rests in Thee," taught throughout the tradition that produced Orange; the quote simply does not carry the claim that saving faith begins from natural powers. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is an anthropological observation about a natural human craving for a hero to revere ("hero-worship"), offered to explain why crowds thronged to John — and the preacher's own gloss is that this instinct is frustrated and disappointed by every human guide until Christ answers it. Orange's canon 5 condemns the claim that the beginning of saving faith and the desire to believe arise from nature rather than grace; a natural restlessness or religious instinct (Augustine's "our heart is restless", the sensus divinitatis) is standard orthodox teaching and says nothing about the origin of faith's beginning. The quote simply does not carry the soteriological claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| Marriage and Celibacy1852-01-11 · #8182 |
| Antinomianism, rejected in the Formula of Concord, 1577: the law is not to be urged on the regenerate“Article VI, Of the Third Use of the Law, rejects the teaching that the law is not to be urged on the regenerate.” Words as recorded in The Lutheran churches, in the Formula of Concord, Article VI, 1577 · Condemned by a church ruling · The Lutheran churches, in the Formula of Concord, 1577 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn in each reading: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings the challenges, in fullRead in the whole sermon Challenge 1: withdrawnRobertson is speaking in his own voice, but the subject is adiaphora — marriage, celibacy, dress, attending a heathen feast — and his point is Paul's own: that Christianity does not settle indifferent matters by casuistic rule but by principle applied in conscience. Christian liberty in things indifferent is mainstream teaching in both Lutheran and Reformed traditions and is not the denial of the law's use among the regenerate; indeed he immediately asserts what Christianity "does demand" and that "a distinct duty arises from this principle," and closes by naming it "our duty." The Formula's Article VI condemns holding that the law has no place in the preaching and exhortation of Christians, which is narrower and other than what this sentence says. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Robertson expounding Paul's ruling on matters of indifference in 1 Corinthians 7 — dress, feast-attendance, marriage or celibacy — and his point is that these outward practices are not prescribed by rule but left to conscience. That is ordinary Protestant teaching on Christian liberty in adiaphora, not the antinomian claim that the law is not to be urged on the regenerate; Robertson in the very next breath presses a demand on believers ("what it does demand is this... you are to live in a spirit higher and loftier than that of the world") and throughout the sermon speaks of "bounden duty" and "duties to be done to-day." The evidence therefore does not carry the Article VI proposition put upon it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is spoken in Robertson's own voice, but its subject is adiaphora — marriage, celibacy, dress, meat at heathen feasts, slavery — where he is restating Paul's rule that indifferent things are left to conscience, which is mainstream teaching (the Formula of Concord itself devotes Article X to such things) and is the ordinary "spirit, not letter" contrast of 2 Cor 3:6 and Rom 7:6. Article VI condemns the refusal to preach and urge God's law upon the born again; Robertson does the opposite in the same breath — "what it does demand is this... you are to live in a spirit higher and loftier than that of the world," and "a distinct duty arises from this principle." The quote therefore does not put the condemned position in this preacher's mouth. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Read in the reframes alone Challenge 1: withdrawnRobertson does say this in his own voice, but the sentence is his gloss on Paul's handling of adiaphora — marriage, celibacy, heathen feasts, slavery — and he spells out exactly what he means by it in the next clause: "you shall use this particular dress... you shall lead, you shall not lead a married life," with application "left to every man's individual conscience." That is Christian liberty in indifferent things, not the antinomian claim that the law is not to be urged on the regenerate; he immediately goes on to press a demand on believers ("what it does demand is this... you are to live in a spirit higher and loftier than that of the world") and devotes the rest of the sermon to duties to be done today. The quote therefore does not carry the proposition Formula of Concord VI condemns. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnRobertson does say this in his own voice, but the sentence is his summary of Paul's ruling on things indifferent — marriage, celibacy, dress, attending a heathen feast, slavery — where "Christianity consists of principles, but the application of those principles is left to every man's individual conscience." It is a claim about Christian liberty in adiaphora, not the claim that the law is not to be urged on the regenerate; indeed he immediately presses obligation on believers ("what it does demand is this," "a distinct duty arises from this principle," "a social life becomes our bounden duty"). The Formula of Concord's Article VI target — withholding the preaching of the law from the reborn — is not what this quote carries. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is Robertson's own voice, but in context it is about adiaphora — Paul's refusal to legislate on marriage, celibacy, diet, slavery and dress — and he glosses it immediately: "Christianity consists of principles, but the application of those principles is left to every man's individual conscience," and "what it does demand is this... you are to live in a spirit higher and loftier than that of the world." That is Christian liberty in indifferent things plus a demand for obedience, not the Formula of Concord's condemned claim that the law must not be urged upon the regenerate; the same sermon repeatedly presses duty on believers ("a social life becomes our bounden duty", "there are duties to be done to-day"). The quote therefore does not carry the proposition put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Christian Aim and Motive1852-01-04 · #8180 |
| Eutychianism, rejected at the Council of Chalcedon, 451: resists those who imagine a mixture or confusion of the two natures of Christ“Its preamble 'anathematizes those who foolishly talk of two natures of our Lord before the union, conceiving that after the union there was only one', 'resists those who imagine a mixture or confusion of the two natures of Christ', and 'drives away those who fancy his form of a servant is of an heavenly or some substance other than that which was taken of us'.” Words as recorded in Council of Chalcedon, Definition of Faith, preamble anathemas, 451-10-22 · Condemned by a council · Council of Chalcedon, 451 · source: The Definition of Faith and canons of the Council of Chalcedon | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnRobertson's claim is that human nature, made in God's image, has an affinity or kinship with the divine such that the Word could assume it — the ordinary patristic and Reformed point that man is capax Dei, deployed here against the Socinian denial of the incarnation. He speaks of Humanity and Divinity being "united in the person of the Redeemer," which is Chalcedonian language, and his water/oil analogy is used to establish kinship, not to assert that the two natures were blended or confused into one. A mainstream tradition teaches this sentence without teaching the mixture Chalcedon resists. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe condemned position is a mixture or confusion of the two natures in Christ, but the quoted passage never says the natures blended into one; its "mingle" language is a general premise about dissimilar substances, and the conclusion drawn is only that human nature must be kindred to God's for the incarnation to be possible — an image-of-God/capacity-for-God argument the surrounding paragraphs use to ground the command "Be ye perfect" and to answer the Socinian objection. Asserting kinship between humanity and divinity is not asserting that the two natures were confounded; the preacher in fact leaves the union in "the person of the Redeemer" intact. The evidence therefore does not carry the claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe preacher's claim in this passage is that human nature is kindred to the divine — that there are "germs" of God's nature in man, grounded in the image-of-God and the fatherhood of God — and he deploys it expressly against the Socinian denial of the incarnation. He nowhere asserts that the two natures mixed or were confused; he says they "were united in the person of the Redeemer," which is Chalcedon's own language, and his premise is in fact that genuinely dissimilar things cannot mingle. The condemned position is a mixture or confusion of the natures in Christ; teaching that humanity is capable of union with God (capax Dei, 2 Pet 1:4) is ordinary teaching and does not carry that claim, so the quote will not bear the weight put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Christian Aim and Motive1852-01-04 · #8180 |
| Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and…“Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.” Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Tripartite Tractate, NHC I,5; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library) | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnRobertson does assert, in his own voice, that something indestructible in man is of divine origin — but he immediately glosses it as "the remains of a majesty which, though it may be sullied, can never be entirely lost," i.e. the imago Dei marred by the Fall, which he names explicitly. The kinship of human nature with the divine as the precondition of a real incarnation is a classical patristic argument (Irenaeus, Athanasius, Eastern theosis), and is the opposite of the Gnostic scheme, which disparages the material order and makes incarnation impossible. Nor does the sermon recast the predicament as ignorance of a heavenly origin rather than guilt; it keeps the Fall and sin in place and locates salvation in self-sacrifice and the cross, so the condemned proposition's distinctive elements are absent. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnRobertson does ask the question in his own voice and plainly affirms it ("this conviction of the divine origin, and consequent perfectibility of our nature"), so voice is not the problem. But what he asserts is kinship with God grounded in creation and the imago Dei — explicitly universal ("Nor is this power confined to the best of mankind, but is possessed, to some extent at least, by all"), explicitly framed by the Fall ("the remains of a majesty which, though it may be sullied, can never be entirely lost"), and deployed to defend the incarnation against the Socinians. The condemned proposition is narrower and other: a divine seed in SOME human beings, alien to the material order, with ignorance rather than guilt as the predicament. Mainstream Christian teaching on the image of God and partaking of the divine nature (2 Pet 1:4, patristic theosis) says Robertson's sentence without saying the Gnostic one. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnRobertson does assert the sentence in his own voice, but what he asserts is the ordinary doctrine of the imago Dei — that human nature bears a God-given kinship with God, which he deploys (against the Socinians) as the precondition of the Incarnation and of the command "Be ye perfect." He makes it universal ("possessed, to some extent at least, by all") and describes it as "the remains of a majesty which, though it may be sullied" by the Fall, i.e. a created likeness marred by guilt — not a pneumatic spark in some men that is alien to the material order, and not a predicament of ignorance and forgetfulness rather than guilt. The Gnostic proposition is a sharpening this sermon does not make. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Christian Aim and Motive1852-01-04 · #8180 |
| Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: Because God commands, the human being must be able to obey“Because God commands, the human being must be able to obey — 'if I ought, I can'.” Words as recorded in Pelagius, Epistula ad Demetriadem (Letter to Demetrias), Ad Demetriadem 2-8, 16, 413 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnRobertson is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence is doing the standard patristic work of arguing that the incarnation presupposes a kinship between divine and human nature (he raises it expressly against "the Socinian argument"), i.e. the imago Dei / capax Dei — taught across mainstream traditions without any Pelagian claim about unaided moral ability. Far from "if I ought, I can," he says in the same sermon that perfection is "that perfection towards which we shall for ever tend, but which we can never attain," and that "man cannot be satisfied with his own works." The command grounds an aspiration rooted in created likeness, not a demonstrated power to obey, so the condemned proposition is not what this sentence asserts. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnRobertson does assert this in his own voice, but what he asserts is the kinship of human nature with God — the imago Dei and 2 Peter 1:4's "partakers of the divine nature" — as the ground of the Incarnation's possibility, which is standard patristic and mainstream teaching (and is here aimed at the Socinian denial, not at grace). He does not claim that the command proves man can fulfil it: in the same sermon he says perfection is "that perfection towards which we shall for ever tend, but which we can never attain," which is the opposite of "if I ought, I can," and he says nothing to deny the necessity of grace, which is what Carthage 418 condemned. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnRobertson is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence claims only that human nature is kindred to God's — the imago Dei, in the very language of 2 Peter 1:4 ("partakers of the divine nature") — as the precondition of the incarnation and of any call to Godlikeness; that is ordinary catholic and Reformed teaching on man's created capacity for God, not the Pelagian inference that command entails power to obey. The sermon in fact denies the condemned proposition, calling perfection "that perfection towards which we shall for ever tend, but which we can never attain," and "heights to which it can never attain," and denying any satisfaction in man's own works and performances. A capacity for likeness is not an ability to fulfil the command unaided, which is what Carthage condemned. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Christian Aim and Motive1852-01-04 · #8180 |
| Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace…“The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace then does the rest.” Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 8, 13, 19, 20, 22, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about the power of self-forgetfulness or self-sacrifice — illustrated by the condemned criminal and the Indian who will not betray his country — which Robertson offers as evidence of the "remains of a majesty which, though it may be sullied, can never be entirely lost," i.e. a defaced but surviving image of God. That is ordinary teaching (including Reformed teaching on the remnant imago Dei and natural civic virtue) and says nothing about a residual capacity by which a person may initiate the seeking of God with grace completing the work, which is the specific thing Orange II condemned. The evidence carries no claim about the beginning of faith or salvation arising from the unaided will, so it cannot bear the proposition put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is part of Robertson's argument that traces of the divine image survive in human nature, illustrated by the power of self-forgetfulness found even in a condemned criminal or a "barbarous Indian." It says nothing about the will's capacity to initiate the seeking of God, nor about grace completing what a person begins — the two elements that make the proposition the semi-Pelagian one Orange condemned. Remnants of the imago Dei and natural capacity for self-giving are taught across mainstream traditions without any claim that the initium fidei arises from man, so the evidence does not carry the claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about the universal human power of self-sacrifice, offered as evidence that man's nature is kindred to God's and so capable of the incarnation and of the command "Be ye perfect." Robertson says nothing here about a residual capacity of the will by which a person may initiate seeking God with grace completing the work; he makes no claim about the order of grace and human initiative at all. The surrounding argument ("the remains of a majesty which, though it may be sullied, can never be entirely lost") concerns the imago Dei, which mainstream traditions affirm without teaching the semi-Pelagian proposition condemned at Orange. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| Unity and Peace1851-02-09 · #8179 |
| Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: Because God commands, the human being must be able to obey“Because God commands, the human being must be able to obey — 'if I ought, I can'.” Words as recorded in Pelagius, Epistula ad Demetriadem (Letter to Demetrias), Ad Demetriadem 2-8, 16, 413 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence is in the preacher's own voice, but what it infers from the apostolic command is that peace is a duty and that its absence carries blame — "if there be not peace but discord in the heart, there is something wrong." That commands imply obligation and culpability is ordinary orthodox teaching across traditions; it is not the Pelagian axiom of unaided natural ability. The sermon itself locates the power elsewhere: peace is "received, and not done," something that "will enter there, if you do not thwart it," by "a Spirit that will take possession of your soul," and "Give us the living Spirit of God, and we shall be one" — "we are recipients, not creators." A single clause about peace being "within the reach of our own wills" cannot be made to carry a general anthropological claim the surrounding argument contradicts. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence does echo the "if I ought, I can" form, but the condemned proposition is an anthropology: unaided natural ability to fulfil God's commands apart from grace. Robertson is arguing only that peace, being commanded of Christians, is therefore a duty whose absence is culpable — ordinary preaching on responsibility — and the same sermon explicitly locates the power outside the natural will: peace is "the peace that is received," "In this world we are recipients, not creators," "Give us the living Spirit of God." On that reading the sentence is taught by mainstream traditions without any Pelagian claim about natural ability, so the classification cannot stand. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnRobertson does infer in his own voice from Paul's command that peace is a duty and therefore attainable, but that inference is ordinary orthodox pastoral reasoning: God does not command the impossible of those under grace, and a duty entails blame when neglected. Read in the sentence and sermon it came from, the attainability is explicitly not natural autonomy — he ends by teaching that peace is "a something received, and not done," that "in this world we are recipients, not creators," and that the enabling power is the Spirit ("Give us the living Spirit of God"). Pelagius's claim is ability by nature apart from grace; this sermon grounds the ability in a gift received, so the condemned proposition is not what is being asserted. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| Unity and Peace1851-02-09 · #8179 |
| Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice“Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice.” Words as recorded in Fausto Sozzini, De Jesu Christo Servatore, De Jesu Christo Servatore, parts I-III, 1594 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnWhat the preacher asserts in his own voice is divine simplicity: that God's justice and love are not two competing attributes needing an "expedient" to reconcile them — "God's justice and love are one." That is ordinary mainstream teaching (Anselm, Aquinas, the Reformed scholastics all deny any real discord among the divine attributes) and is held by theologians who nonetheless affirm that Christ satisfies divine justice; what he rejects is a caricatured framing of the atonement as a clever device resolving an internal conflict in God, not the satisfaction of justice itself. The Socinian proposition is the far sharper claim that Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice, and this sentence, used here to ground the "peace of God" in His unity, does not carry it. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe preacher is speaking in his own voice, but what he asserts is that there is no discord between God's justice and His love and so no need of an "expedient" to reconcile two warring attributes — a statement of divine simplicity and harmony of attributes that Augustinian, Thomist and Reformed writers teach routinely while still affirming that Christ satisfies divine justice. What he rejects is one popular *description* of the atonement (a "clever expedient"), not satisfaction itself; the words never say Christ does not save by satisfying justice. Since a mainstream reading carries this sentence without carrying Sozzini's denial of satisfaction, the classification cannot stand. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is spoken in the preacher's own voice, but what it denies is a particular framing of the atonement — that it is a "clever expedient" needed to reconcile two attributes supposedly at odds in God — not that Christ's work satisfies divine justice. His actual claim is about the harmony and simplicity of the divine attributes ("God's justice and love are one"), which mainstream orthodox theology affirms while still holding satisfaction; indeed the rejection of discord within God is a standard point of divine simplicity. The quote nowhere says Christ does not save by satisfying justice, so it cannot carry the Socinian proposition put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Sacrifice of Christ1850-06-23 · #8175 |
| Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice“Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice.” Words as recorded in Fausto Sozzini, De Jesu Christo Servatore, De Jesu Christo Servatore, parts I-III, 1594 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe proposition denies that Christ saves by satisfying divine justice — a claim about penal satisfaction. The evidence span says nothing about justice, penalty or satisfaction; it claims the one offering must be "completed and repeated" in the believer's own self-offering, which is a claim about subjective appropriation, made while Robertson is salvaging what he takes to be the truth inside the Romish doctrine of the mass and glossing Colossians 1:24. He affirms in the same sentence that "there is one offering once offered for all," so the span cannot be made to bear a denial of satisfaction without importing other, unquoted material from the sermon. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Robertson's own voice, but it speaks to how the one offering must be appropriated and reproduced in the believer's self-offering — his gloss on Colossians 1:24 and his attempt to salvage a truth from the Romish doctrine of the mass. It says nothing about divine justice or satisfaction, and the claim that Christ's sacrifice avails only where it is taken up and lived out is taught by mainstream traditions (Catholic teaching on union with Christ's sacrifice, and the ordinary insistence that the atonement must be applied) without any denial that Christ satisfied justice. The Socinian proposition is a sharper and different claim than this sentence carries. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Robertson's own claim, but what it claims is that Christ's one offering must be appropriated and reproduced in the self-offering of believers — his way of salvaging a "truth" he finds buried in the Roman doctrine of the mass, glossed by Colossians 1:24. It says nothing about divine justice or satisfaction, and the proposition charged ("Christ does not save by satisfying divine justice") is a claim about the ground of atonement, not about its subjective appropriation. Participation in Christ's sacrifice, and the insistence that the atonement profits only those who live in Him, is taught across mainstream traditions (the BCP's "ourselves, our souls and bodies, to be a reasonable, holy and living sacrifice") without any denial of satisfaction; whatever Robertson's wider views, this sentence does not carry the Socinian claim placed on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Sacrifice of Christ1850-06-23 · #8175 |
| Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: guilt and punishment are not transferable between persons“Socinus's argument in De Jesu Christo Servatore is that forgiveness and payment are mutually exclusive — a debt paid is not a debt forgiven — that guilt and punishment are not transferable between persons, that an eternal penalty cannot be discharged by a temporary death, and that God, being free, may simply forgive.” Words as recorded in Fausto Sozzini, De Jesu Christo Servatore, De Jesu Christo Servatore, parts I-III, 1594 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence rejects a particular psychological theory — that Christ, by omniscience, felt the subjective remorse of every sin ever committed — which the preacher calls "fanciful and sentimental" and a "fictitious and shadowy transaction." That is a claim about Christ's conscience, not a denial that guilt or punishment can pass between persons; indeed the very next paragraphs assert the opposite, that the Pharisees bore "the blood of righteous Abel" and that "Similarly we are guilty of the death of Christ," and that He "was the victim of the sin of all." Denying that Christ had a morbid guilty conscience is compatible with mainstream substitutionary teaching, so the evidence cannot carry the Socinian proposition. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (1 Kings 14:22) Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Robertson rejecting one particular sentimental hypothesis — that Christ's own conscience was subjectively tormented with a felt guilt for sins He never committed — which he calls "fanciful," "unscriptural," and dangerous because it makes the Atonement "a fictitious and shadowy transaction." It is a claim about the psychology of Christ's mind, not a denial that guilt or punishment can pass between persons. Indeed, in the very next breath he offers "a way however, much more appalling and much more true," and then affirms at length that Christ "was the victim of the sin of all," that the Pharisees bore "the blood of righteous Abel," and that "similarly we are guilty of the death of Christ" — i.e. he affirms shared and transferred guilt rather than denying it. The Socinian proposition is simply not what this sentence carries. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (1 Kings 14:22) Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence rejects a psychological claim — that Christ's own conscience subjectively felt oppressed, as by remorse, for sins He never committed — which the preacher calls "fanciful and sentimental" and unscriptural; it says nothing about whether guilt or punishment can be borne by one for another. Indeed, immediately after, he argues at length for exactly such transfer of guilt ("the Pharisees were declared by the Saviour to be guilty of the blood of Zacharias... Similarly we are guilty of the death of Christ... for your sin He died"), and affirms "the death of Christ was the sacrifice of God." Orthodox writers routinely distinguish forensic imputation of guilt from a morbid consciousness of personal sin in Christ, so the quote does not carry the Socinian proposition that guilt and punishment are untransferable. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (1 Kings 14:22) |
Withdrawn passages, 10 to a page, each with its challenges in full: 1–10 · 11–16
How these were counted
The part of each printed sermon read: teaching 21 — each part named with how many printed sermons it was read in.
- printed sermons
- 21
- window
- every printed sermon held here
- read by
- an AI model; details in About the study
We checked the sermons of Frederick W. Robertson against 115 rejected teachings, reading 21 whole sermons and the reframes of 21 sermons.
17 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.
The withdrawn passages come from 8 of the 21 sermons checked.
Read whole. 21 of the 21 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 15 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Read in their reframes. 21 of the 21 sermons in the basis above were read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 4 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.