What was preached

All churches › Johannes Tauler › Teachings the church historically rejected

Johannes Tauler

What do the ▸ links mean?

Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →

0 published · 20 withdrawn, of 20 flagged in 17 sermons read

No passage is published and none is waiting to be checked: every passage that looked like a match was withdrawn on challenge.

Show the 20 withdrawn passages

Passages 11–20 of 20

Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.

SermonWhat was saidMatchesResult
SERMON XIX. On the Nativity of Our Ladypreached c. 1340 · #8387

the man who does not wish to hinder the Eternal Birth, but would make an entrance for it by means of the desire, must remember that the pleasures of the senses in nature, and in the creature, are hindrances

paragraph 3, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

But the man who does not wish to hinder the Eternal Birth, but would make an entrance for it by means of the desire, must remember that the pleasures of the senses in nature, and in the creature, are hindrances; for the less of them, the more of the other; for the more cold goes out, the more warmth will come in; neither must man remain in his chamber idle and careless, and in gloomy weakness. Some men go about blindly, and all that they do is done blindly and foolishly in unfruitfulness.

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: the claim that God awaits our will to be cleansed rather than causing that will

“Canon 5 anathematises the claim that the beginning of faith and the very desire to believe belong to us by nature and not by a gift of grace; canon 6 the claim that God has mercy when, apart from his grace, we believe, will, desire, strive, labour, pray, watch, study, seek, ask or knock; canon 7 the claim that we can make any right choice relating to salvation, or assent to the preaching of the gospel, by natural powers without the illumination of the Holy Spirit; canon 4 the claim that God awaits our will to be cleansed rather than causing that will.”

Words as recorded in Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), canon 4, 529-07-03 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is ascetical counsel about removing impediments — that sensual pleasures hinder the Eternal Birth, so one who would "make an entrance for it by means of the desire" must renounce them. It says nothing about the origin of that desire, and so does not assert Orange canon 4's claim that God merely waits upon a will he does not himself cause. The sermon in fact says the opposite nearby: the text is spoken by "the Heavenly Father Who guides and entices us to this birth," and a glimpse "will be given" so "that their longing may be excited and drawn forth to desire more and more" — the desire is attributed to God's drawing. Removing obstacles to a grace that itself stirs the longing is ordinary preparatory teaching, not the condemned proposition.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is spoken in the preacher's own voice, but it says only that sensual pleasures hinder the Eternal Birth and must be set aside by one who would open a door to it — ascetical counsel about removing obstacles, which is standard Catholic teaching on cooperation with grace. It makes no claim at all about the origin of the desire, which is what Orange canon 4 condemns (that God waits on a will to be cleansed that does not itself come from the Holy Spirit's infusion). Indeed the same sermon attributes the drawing to "the words of the Heavenly Father Who guides and entices us to this birth," so the quote cannot be made to carry a denial that grace causes the will.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnOrange canon 4 condemns the specific claim that God merely waits for a will to be cleansed which does not itself come from the infusion and working of the Holy Spirit. The quoted sentence says only that sensual pleasures in nature and the creature are hindrances to the Eternal Birth, and that one who would make room for it must recognise them as such — ordinary ascetical teaching on removing impediments, which says nothing about the origin or causation of the desire. Indeed the same sermon attributes the desire to God's prior action ("These are the words of the Heavenly Father Who guides and entices us to this birth"), so the evidence does not carry the condemned claim.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XIX. On the Nativity of Our Ladypreached c. 1340 · #8387

as long as these births find place in thee with thy knowledge and consent, can never bring forth His birth in thee

paragraph 1, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

births that are born of man. These are temporal, transitory, sensual, harmful things; delight and satisfaction in the creature, whether animate or inanimate; friendship and society; clothes, food, and all the things in which man delights. These things create restlessness in thee; and they beget such births in thee, so that God, as long as these births find place in thee with thy knowledge and consent, can never bring forth His birth in thee, in the joyful possession of thy heart. Some trifle, however small and mean it may be, takes from thee and robs thee of thy greatest good, and of the blissful birth that God desires to bring forth in thee; and it also takes away from thee all desire for it, and the consolation that thou oughtest to have after this birth; all this

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence says only that God's birth in the soul is hindered while a person knowingly and willingly harbours attachment to creatures — an impediment claim, not a claim that grace waits upon and responds to a prior human initiative. That voluntary clinging to sin obstructs grace is ordinary Catholic (and broadly Christian) teaching, and the sermon itself places the initiative with God, who "guides and entices us to this birth" and "desired to raise us up again." Nothing in the evidence has God awaiting the human turn, so the condemned semi-Pelagian proposition is not carried by it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted clause says only that God's birth cannot come to fruition in a person who knowingly and willingly keeps "strange births" (inordinate attachment to creatures) in place — a statement about a self-imposed impediment to grace, not a statement that grace waits upon and responds to a prior human initiative. Orange II condemned the claim that the beginning of faith and the turning to God originate in man with grace following after; this sentence makes no such claim, and the same sermon has the Father Himself "guid[ing] and entic[ing] us to this birth," i.e. grace moving first. Teaching that voluntary clinging to sin obstructs grace is ordinary Augustinian and Catholic doctrine, so the evidence will not carry the semi-Pelagian proposition put on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted words say that God's birth in the soul is hindered while sin is held with knowledge and consent — a claim about impediment, not about grace waiting on a human turn. Orange II condemns the view that the initiative is man's and grace merely responds; this sermon puts the initiative on God's side, since the Father "guides and entices us to this birth," the longing is "excited and drawn forth" by a glimpse God gives, and the first of the two processions is "of God to us." That consented-to sin obstructs grace is ordinary ascetical teaching and does not carry the condemned proposition.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XX. The first Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8388

if I am to come to Him, I must receive Him into myself. So much of mine, so much of His; it is an equal bargain.

paragraph 2, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

the Highest, He desires to dwell also in our highest places, that is in our uppermost and innermost love and desires. He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest, and lead the lowest with the highest unto Himself. If we do this, He will draw us after Himself into His highest and most secret place. For thus it must needs be; if I am to come to Him, I must receive Him into myself. So much of mine, so much of His; it is an equal bargain.

2 teachings

  • Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace…

    “The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace then does the rest.”

    Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 8, 13, 19, 20, 22, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnTauler is speaking in his own voice, but the quoted sentence is about reciprocal self-surrender to a Christ who is already drawing — the immediately preceding lines are "I, if I be lifted up... will draw all things unto Me," "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest," and "If we do this, He will draw us after Himself." The "equal bargain" asserts that the measure of heart given over is the measure of Christ's indwelling; it says nothing about a residual natural capacity in the fallen will to seek God prior to grace, which is the specific structure Orange II condemned. The sermon in fact insists the opposite elsewhere — "It is necessary, on account of man's human weakness, that he should be protected by God's help" — and the exhortation to cooperate with grace already received is ordinary teaching, not the condemned semi-Pelagian initium fidei.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted line is Tauler describing the reciprocity of mystical union — that Christ indwells to the measure that one yields the "ground" of the heart to Him — and it sits immediately after "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest" and under the sermon's governing text, "I, if I be lifted up, will draw all things unto Me," which places the initiative with Christ's drawing. The condemned proposition is specifically about a residual capacity of the fallen will to seek God prior to grace, with grace supplying the remainder; the "equal bargain" says nothing about the state of the will or the priority of human initiative, and the sermon elsewhere insists "it is necessary, on account of man's human weakness, that he should be protected by God's help." Cooperation with grace in surrender is ordinary teaching and is not what Orange condemned.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe condemned proposition is specifically about the origin of the movement toward God — a residual natural capacity by which a person may begin to seek God, grace completing what the will starts. Tauler's line says nothing about the will's condition or about who initiates; it sits inside a passage governed by Christ's prior drawing ("I, if I be lifted up... will draw all things unto Me"; "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest"), and the "equal bargain" is the mystics' reciprocity trope for receiving the Christ who is already drawing. Mainstream teaching on cooperation with prevenient grace says this sentence without saying the semi-Pelagian one, and the sermon elsewhere insists "it is necessary, on account of man's human weakness, that he should be protected by God's help."
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
  • Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

    “On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

    Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is in Tauler's own voice, but its content is the necessity of receiving Christ, set inside a frame where Christ's drawing is prior and primary ("I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all things unto Me"; "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest"). The proposition's distinctive content — that God awaits a human turn and grace comes only as a response to it — is absent: nothing here makes the human movement unaided or first, and the reciprocity of "so much of mine, so much of His" is the ordinary ascetic language of correspondence to grace, which Catholic teaching on cooperation holds without denying prevenient grace. The sermon elsewhere credits "the grace which God has given to your Order" and says man "should be protected by God's help," which tells against reading this line as grace following initiative.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnTauler does speak in his own voice here, but the sentence expresses the mystical commonplace of reciprocity in self-surrender — the measure in which I empty myself and receive Christ is the measure of His indwelling — which is ordinary Catholic teaching on cooperation with grace, not a claim that grace is given in response to an ungraced human initiative. The immediate frame makes Christ's action prior and causal ("I, if I be lifted up... will draw all things unto Me"; "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest"), so nothing in the passage has God awaiting the human turn. Orange II condemns grace that follows and answers human initiative; a sentence about receptive cooperation with a drawing already begun does not carry that proposition.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is Tauler's own, but it says nothing about God waiting on a human turn or grace arriving in response to it: it is a statement of reciprocal self-giving — the measure of heart I yield is the measure of His indwelling — and it sits inside an exposition whose governing claim is that Christ draws first ("I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all things unto Me," "He will draw up the lowest powers to the highest"). Orange's canons condemn a view about the priority of grace to the beginning of faith; the "equal bargain" line addresses the depth of union under a drawing already begun by Christ, which is ordinary cooperation-with-grace language. The quote therefore does not carry the proposition put on it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Withdrawn
withdrawn on challenge; why, for each teaching, is under its name
read in the whole sermon
SERMON XXI. The Second Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8389

In that secret place the created spirit is brought back again to its uncreatedness, where it had been from everlasting before it was created, and where it recognises itself as God in God, and yet in itself as of the creature, and created.

paragraph 10, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

the secret place, the Holy of Holies. Offer up thy sacrifice, and especially offer up thyself, and enter in, and hide there thy secret mind in the mystery of the Divine Abyss. As the prophet said in the Psalter: “Lord, Thou shalt hide them in the secret of Thy Face.” In that secret place the created spirit is brought back again to its uncreatedness, where it had been from everlasting before it was created, and where it recognises itself as God in God, and yet in itself as of the creature, and created. But in God all things are God, who rest on this foundation. Proclus says: “When man once enters here, whatever may befall the outer man, sorrow, poverty or whatever it may be, he heeds it not.” As the Prophet says: “Thou shalt hide them...from the disturbance of men.”

2 teachings

  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and…

    “Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

    Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Tripartite Tractate, NHC I,5; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

    withdrawn in each reading: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading

    read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings

    the challenges, in full

    Read in the whole sermon

    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence describes the soul's eternal standing in God before creation (the Rhineland-mystical "uncreated ground"), and in the same breath qualifies it: the spirit knows itself "in itself as of the creature, and created." That is the opposite of a divine element that does not belong to the created/material order, and it is said of every man who climbs the mountain, not of "some human beings." The proposition also requires the predicament to be ignorance rather than guilt, whereas this sermon is built on sin, repentance, confession, purgatory and condemnation ("it will most assuredly cause your condemnation").
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical exemplarism: the soul's "uncreatedness" is its eternal existence in God's knowledge before creation, a doctrine taught in mainstream Catholic (Augustinian–Thomist) theology, and Tauler himself immediately blocks the Gnostic reading by adding that the spirit knows itself "in itself as of the creature, and created." Nothing here posits a divine element that does not belong to the material order. The proposition's in-context clause — predicament as ignorance rather than guilt — is contradicted by this very sermon, which is built on sin, repentance, confession, condemnation and purgatory.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnTauler is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence is the standard exemplarist language of Rhineland mysticism — the soul returning to its eternal archetype in the divine mind — and he immediately guards it: the spirit knows itself "in itself as of the creature, and created." He grounds man's highest nature in the imago Dei ("in the Image and Likeness of God"), a created likeness, not a pre-cosmic spark alien to matter, and he never restricts it to "some" human beings. The second half of the proposition is directly contradicted by the sermon, which is saturated with sin, repentance, purgatory and condemnation ("if ye willingly allow yourselves to be possessed by the creature... it will most assuredly cause your condemnation"), so the predicament here is guilt, not forgetfulness of origin.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

    Read in the reframes alone

    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Rhineland-mystical language about the soul's return to its eternal ground in God, and the preacher qualifies it in the same breath — "and yet in itself as of the creature, and created" — which denies precisely what the proposition requires: an element that is divine by origin and does not belong to the created/material order. Nor does it posit a spark in "some" human beings; it speaks of the created spirit as such. The proposition's second half also fails in context: this sermon frames the human predicament as sin, guilt, repentance, confession, purgatory and possible condemnation, not as ignorance or forgetfulness of a divine origin.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is Tauler's own, but it states the standard Rhineland/scholastic doctrine that the soul has an eternal exemplar in God — existing "in God" before it was created — and he immediately supplies the orthodox qualification in the same breath: "and yet in itself as of the creature, and created." That is the opposite of a divine element that does not belong to the created order. The proposition also requires that the human predicament be ignorance of this origin rather than guilt, and this sermon is saturated with sin, repentance, confession, condemnation and purgatory, so the condemned position's defining move is absent.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is Tauler's own, but it states the Rhineland/exemplarist doctrine that the soul pre-exists eternally in the divine ideas and returns to that ground — and he immediately qualifies it: the spirit recognises itself "yet in itself as of the creature, and created." That explicit affirmation of creatureliness is the opposite of a pneuma that does not belong to the created order, and the whole sermon locates the human predicament in sin, repentance, confession and purgatory rather than in ignorance of a divine origin. Mainstream Catholic mystical theology teaches this sentence without teaching Gnostic anthropology.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge

    “Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge.”

    Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Gospel of Truth, NHC I,3; Apocryphon of John, the conclusion; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this

    read in the reframes alone

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe proposition has three joined parts — salvation as awakening, recognition of an origin above, and a revealer who saves by imparting knowledge — and the quoted sentence carries none of them as a soteriology. Tauler is describing the soul's return to its eternal ground in God at the summit of a sermon whose whole account of salvation is the Cross, suffering, self-denial and dying to one's own will ("it was necessary that Christ should suffer before He entered into His glory"); there is no revealer bringing gnosis and no claim that knowledge rather than Christ's passion saves. Whatever else may be said of the "God in God" language, it is not the Gnostic awakening-by-knowledge scheme being asserted here.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is Tauler's own, but it does not carry the proposition's substance: there is no revealer imparting saving knowledge and no awakening to an origin "above" as the mechanism of salvation. In this sermon the way to that "secret place" is explicitly the Cross — self-denial, suffering, repentance, dying to one's own will — and the quoted line immediately qualifies itself ("and yet in itself as of the creature, and created"), which is the ordinary scholastic-mystical doctrine of the creature's eternal exemplar in God, not gnostic soteriology.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe condemned proposition has three joined parts — salvation as awakening, recognition of a pre-existent origin above, and a revealer who effects it by imparting knowledge — and the quoted sentence carries only a version of the second. Tauler is describing the soul's eternal existence in God before creation and its return in contemplative union, and he immediately qualifies it ("and yet in itself as of the creature, and created"). The sermon's actual soteriology is the opposite of gnosis: salvation comes by taking up the Cross, dying to self-will, and the death of Christ, with no revealer imparting saving knowledge anywhere in it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Withdrawn
withdrawn on challenge; why, for each teaching, is under its name
SERMON XXV. All Saints’ Daypreached c. 1340 · #8393

always excepting the blessed Friends of God, who are the most blessed of all here; for they have done with weeping for their own sins, and may not mourn for them any more; and yet they have not ceased weeping, for they weep for the sins and infirmities of their neighbours.

paragraph 15, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

Thirdly, our Lord said: “Blessed are they that mourn, for they shall be comforted.” In one sense He means those who suffer; in another sense, those who mourn for their sins, always excepting the blessed Friends of God, who are the most blessed of all here; for they have done with weeping for their own sins, and may not mourn for them any more; and yet they have not ceased weeping, for they weep for the sins and infirmities of their neighbours. We read that St Dominic asked one of his companions, who was weeping bitterly, why he wept. He replied: “Dear father, because of my sins.” Then said the Saint: “No, dear son, they have been sufficiently mourned for; but I beseech thee, dear son, to

Pelagianism, rejected at the Council of Carthage, 418: that the saints say 'forgive us our trespasses' only on others' behalf

“Canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Caelestius — eight canons anathematising, in turn: that Adam was created mortal and would have died apart from sin; that infants are not baptised for the remission of original sin; that grace remits past sins only and does not assist against future ones; that grace only illuminates the understanding without also enabling the doing; that grace makes obedience easier rather than possible; that 'if we say we have no sin we deceive ourselves' is said only out of humility; that the saints say 'forgive us our trespasses' only on others' behalf; and that they say it without meaning it of themselves.”

Words as recorded in Council of Carthage, canon 115, 418-05-01 · Condemned by a council · Council of Carthage, 418 · source: Council of Carthage, canons against the heresy of Pelagius and Celestius (Code of Canons of the African Church, canons 108-116)

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe Carthaginian canon condemns a specific claim about the Lord's Prayer: that when saints pray "forgive us our trespasses" they say it not of themselves but only on behalf of others, thereby denying that they have sin needing forgiveness. Tauler's sentence is about penitential weeping under the beatitude "blessed are they that mourn": the Friends of God have sufficiently mourned sins already forgiven and so turn their tears outward to their neighbours — a point he immediately illustrates with St Dominic telling his companion his sins "have been sufficiently mourned for." He nowhere touches the petition for forgiveness, and nowhere claims the saints are without sin; the ordinary Catholic spiritual counsel against endless scrupulosity over forgiven sin, coupled with intercessory sorrow for others, carries this sentence without carrying the condemned proposition.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (2 Samuel 19:28)
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe Carthaginian canon condemns a specific claim about the Lord's Prayer: that the saints utter "forgive us our trespasses" not of themselves but only on behalf of others, i.e. that they have no sin of their own to confess. The quoted passage says nothing about that petition or about sinlessness; it concerns penitential mourning, and the attached Dominic anecdote makes the sense plain — their own sins "have been sufficiently mourned for," so their tears are now better spent on those who will not weep for themselves. Redirecting penitential sorrow toward others' sins once one's own are forgiven and adequately grieved is ordinary ascetical and devotional teaching, and this sermon elsewhere insists on purgatorial purification for sin, which cuts against reading it as a claim of personal sinlessness.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (2 Samuel 19:28)
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe canon condemns a specific claim: that the saints utter the petition "forgive us our trespasses" only on behalf of others and not of themselves — i.e. that they have no sin of their own to confess. Tauler's sentence is about penitential weeping, not about the Lord's Prayer or the confession of sin: it says the Friends of God have finished mourning sins already repented and forgiven, and now direct their tears to their neighbours' sins. That the compunction of advanced souls turns from past (already absolved) sin to intercession for others is commonplace Catholic spiritual teaching — the St Dominic anecdote he then quotes makes exactly that point — and it asserts neither impeccability nor that the saints ask forgiveness only for others.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (2 Samuel 19:28)
SERMON XXV. All Saints’ Daypreached c. 1340 · #8393

waiting to see if we will do better. If we do not improve, we must expect yet heavier and severer plagues.

paragraph 15, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

misery of the sins of the world, and for all its wickedness. For when God allows His anger and His judgments to fall upon us, and we say so many dreadful things about the fire, the floods, the great darkness, strong winds and bad times, then the Saints mourn over all before the Lord, day and night; and He regardeth them and ceaseth, waiting to see if we will do better. If we do not improve, we must expect yet heavier and severer plagues. The clouds hang over us; but they are held up by the weeping of the Friends of God. But, be sure of this, if we do not improve, they will soon fall; and then there will be such tumults and turmoils that we shall be put in mind of the Judgment Day. Those who are now at peace will suffer from great oppression, and the Word of God and

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the reframes alone
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about God's forbearance in temporal judgment: the saints' intercession stays the plagues, and God "ceaseth, waiting to see if we will do better." That is providence and chastisement — the Nineveh pattern of God suspending threatened calamity pending amendment — and not a claim about the order of grace in conversion. Orange condemns the view that saving grace follows and responds to an unaided human turn; nothing in this span speaks to grace, its priority, or its cause, and Tauler elsewhere in the same sermon grounds the saints' state in what "is given to them of grace."
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is about God suspending temporal judgment — plagues, floods, storms — in response to the intercession of the Friends of God, and holding off to see whether people amend. It says nothing about the origin of faith or good will, which is what Orange II condemns: the notion that the human turn precedes and elicits grace. Divine forbearance over temporal chastisement is ordinary scriptural teaching (Nineveh, 2 Peter 3:9), and in this very sermon Tauler grounds the reprieve in God's regard for the prayers of the saints, not in unaided human initiative.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentences concern God's forbearance in temporal judgment — He holds back "heavier and severer plagues" while the Friends of God weep and we are given space to amend — not the order of grace and the will in salvation. Orange condemned the claim that saving grace is given in answer to a prior human movement; divine patience over threatened chastisement (Nineveh, Jeremiah 18, 2 Peter 3:9) is ordinary preaching in every tradition and carries nothing of that claim. The evidence simply does not bear the soteriological proposition laid on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XXXV. The First Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8394

This interior God-man, formed in the Image of God, flies back to His Divine Source and to His first condition before the Creation; and there the pure spirit becomes the Light of Lights.

paragraph 2, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

it cometh nor whither it goeth. Children, this wind is the most interior and sublime man, moulded and formed in the Image of God. This pure man is so far above all knowledge, that all man’s reason and all his works cannot attain nor reach up to Him, because He is so far above the mind of man. This interior God-man, formed in the Image of God, flies back to His Divine Source and to His first condition before the Creation; and there the pure spirit becomes the Light of Lights. To some extent all other lights are extinguished in this Light, for all natural and all imparted light that ever lighted man becomes darkness. The sun obscures the light of all the stars in heaven when it is shining most brightly; and so, when the Divine Light shines into the depths of the

Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and…

“Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Tripartite Tractate, NHC I,5; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

Withdrawn
withdrawn in each reading: the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings
the challenges, in full

Read in the whole sermon

Challenge 1: withdrawnTauler's sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical language about the imago Dei and the soul's eternal exemplar in God — the inner man "formed in the Image of God" returning to its Source — which Catholic mystical theology (Augustinian exemplarism, Eckhart's and Tauler's own tradition) teaches without positing an uncreated divine spark alien to the material order. The proposition further requires that the human predicament be ignorance rather than guilt, and this sermon says the opposite throughout: "the wickedness of our nature is so concealed," the demand to die to nature, to self-surrender and resignation. Nor is the inner man restricted to "some human beings"; Tauler addresses all who would be renewed.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnTauler is speaking in his own voice, but the sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical and scholastic teaching on the imago Dei: the soul created in God's image, with its eternal exemplar in God "before the Creation," returning to its Source and being illumined by the Divine Light. Mainstream Catholic mysticism (and the patristic doctrine of theosis) teaches exactly this without positing a divine spark alien to the material order. The proposition's second half — predicament as ignorance rather than guilt — is also contradicted by the same sermon, which dwells on "the wickedness of our nature," mortification and self-surrender, and insists all men must climb the barren fig tree, not that a special few possess a pneuma.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnTauler's sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical language about the imago Dei (Gen 1:26-27) and the soul's exemplar in God before creation — taught by Augustine, Bonaventure and the whole medieval contemplative tradition without any Gnostic pneuma. It is also not the proposition as stated: Tauler makes the climb open to "all men," not to an elect few carrying a divine element, and he diagnoses the predicament as "the wickedness of our nature," requiring dying to self and resignation, not ignorance in place of guilt.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

Read in the reframes alone

Challenge 1: withdrawnTauler does assert this in his own voice, but the sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical teaching on the imago Dei: the soul made in God's image returning to its eternal exemplar in God and being illumined — a theme Augustine, Aquinas and the whole deification tradition carry without any Gnostic divine spark. The proposition requires a divine element in SOME humans, alien to the material order, with the predicament construed as ignorance rather than guilt; this sermon instead insists on the "wickedness of our nature," self-surrender, mortification and repentance as the path, and applies the image-language to men generally. The sentence therefore fits ordinary mystical anthropology and does not evidence the condemned position.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is Tauler speaking in his own voice, but what he says is the ordinary Rhineland-Augustinian doctrine of the imago Dei (Gen 1:27) and divine exemplarism: the soul, made in God's image, returns to the Source in which it eternally pre-existed as an idea in the divine mind — taught across mainstream Catholic mysticism and scholasticism without any Gnostic pneuma. The condemned proposition further requires that only *some* humans bear this element and that the predicament be ignorance rather than guilt; this sermon teaches the opposite on both counts, locating the image in man as such and framing the problem as "the wickedness of our nature," to be met by mortification, repentance and self-surrender, not by recollection of origin.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is standard Rhineland-mystical language about the imago Dei: the soul, created in God's image, returning to the God who is its Source and to its eternal exemplar "before the Creation," and being flooded with divine light — teaching found throughout orthodox Catholic mysticism and patristic theosis, which holds the image to be created, not an uncreated alien spark. The proposition further requires that the human predicament be ignorance and forgetfulness rather than guilt, whereas this sermon is built on "the wickedness of our nature," dying to nature, discipline and self-surrender — guilt and sin are its driving concern. The condemned Gnostic anthropology is a sharpening of imago-Dei language, and imago-Dei language is not it.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XXXV. The First Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8394

When man strives with all his might and main, in the inner and outer man, he flies up so high in knowledge and love, that no merely human sensual power can attain to him.

paragraph 2, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

in their desires, their love and their intentions. Secondly, our Lord walks on the wings of the eagle; for the eagle flies so high that none can see him. The eagle is the pure man, formed in the Image of God, who flies up with all his strength, both outwardly and inwardly, to the secret places of God. When man strives with all his might and main, in the inner and outer man, he flies up so high in knowledge and love, that no merely human sensual power can attain to him. Our dear Lord also soars on these noble wings. Thirdly, our Lord walks on the wings of the wind; for the wind is so swift and fast that ye know not whence it cometh nor whither it goeth. Children, this wind is the most interior and sublime man, moulded and formed in the Image of God. This pure man is

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace…

“The will is weakened but not destroyed; a residual capacity remains by which a person may seek God, and grace then does the rest.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 8, 13, 19, 20, 22, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence describes the ascetic striving of "the pure man, formed in the Image of God" rising in knowledge and love — spiritual progress by one already within grace — and says nothing about a residual natural capacity by which an unregenerate person initiates the seeking of God with grace supplying the remainder. The sermon itself cuts against that reading: it speaks of "nature and the Grace of God... contending within thee," of these men as "the chosen of our merciful God," and ends with "thou must do nothing and be nothing; and then God will come into thine own house." Cooperative striving under grace is ordinary Catholic ascetical teaching and is not the Pelagian initium fidei that Orange II condemned.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is part of an allegorical exposition of the "wings of the eagle" — it describes the ascent in knowledge and love of a man already "formed in the Image of God," and says nothing about a residual capacity of the will by which a person initiates the seeking of God, with grace then completing it. The sermon in fact runs the other way: nature's works "always have some flaws," nature and grace "contend" within the striver, and the hearer must "do nothing and be nothing" before God will enter. Ordinary ascetical exhortation to strive within grace is not the semi-Pelagian claim Orange condemned, so the evidence does not carry the proposition put on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is part of an allegory on the three "wings" (dove, eagle, wind) and describes the ascetic ascent in knowledge and love of a man already "formed in the Image of God" — it says nothing about a residual capacity of the fallen will initiating the approach to God with grace following after, which is the specific thing Orange condemns. Tauler in fact teaches the contrary in this same sermon: "whatever nature does has always some flaws, and is therefore not quite perfect and pure," and the whole exhortation is that man "must do nothing and be nothing; and then God will come into thine own house." Exhortation to strenuous cooperation with grace is ordinary ascetical teaching and does not carry the claim placed on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XXXVI. The Second Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8395

Therefore I say unto you that God will not take up His abode in a temple which has not thus been cleared.

paragraph 1, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

it may be made clean and pure. For all temples are not made holy by being simply called the houses of God; but God only can make them holy. Therefore this Temple of God is a pure clean heart; and it is truly a Temple of God, where the Eternal God ever dwelleth in truth, when all that is unlike Him has been driven out and cast forth. Therefore I say unto you that God will not take up His abode in a temple which has not thus been cleared. Before a man has one pure thought of God in his heart, a thousand other thoughts enter in, about temporal things, which lead astray these pure thoughts of God and drive them away. It is in this sense that tradesfolk are referred to, and that we are told what they are. Therefore all men, who, of their own free will, live in pleasure,

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence says only that God does not dwell in an uncleansed heart — ordinary ascetical and sanctification teaching across Catholic and Reformed traditions (cf. Matt 5:8, James 4:8), and not a claim about the order of grace and the human will. The surrounding sermon positively excludes the condemned reading: "all temples are not made holy by being simply called the houses of God; but God only can make them holy," the cleansing is "with tears of repentance and the Love of God," and later "to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own, or a striving after his own salvation." Nothing here has God awaiting an unaided human turn before grace responds.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted sentence says only that God does not indwell an uncleansed heart — a commonplace about purity of heart and divine indwelling (Matt. 5:8), not a claim about the order of grace and human initiative. The immediate context cuts directly against the proposition: Tauler says the temple is cleansed "with tears of repentance and the Love of God," that "all temples are not made holy by being simply called the houses of God; but God only can make them holy," and later that "to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own, or a striving after his own salvation." Nothing here describes God waiting on a human turn with grace following after it, so the evidence will not bear the proposition put on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence says only that God does not indwell an uncleansed heart — the ordinary ascetic and Augustinian commonplace behind "blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God," taught across mainstream traditions without any claim that grace waits on unaided human initiative. The preacher expressly removes the Orange reading in the same paragraph: the temple is cleansed "with tears of repentance and the Love of God," and "all temples are not made holy by being simply called the houses of God; but God only can make them holy." He later adds that "to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own, or a striving after his own salvation," which is the opposite of grace responding to a prior human turn.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
SERMON XXXVI. The Second Sermonpreached c. 1340 · #8395

and should humbly crave the mercy and goodness of God, and look upon himself as full of sin at all times; and then he will assuredly be helped by God’s lovingkindness and grace

paragraph 1, in the edition on www.ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

a man looks upon as sins and confesses, are not so serious or so harmful to him as one single sin, of which he makes no account and does not look upon as sin, and in which he wickedly continues. Therefore man should always have a truly humble fear before God the Lord, on account of his unknown sins, and should humbly crave the mercy and goodness of God, and look upon himself as full of sin at all times; and then he will assuredly be helped by God’s lovingkindness and grace. But the man who excuses himself, and goes on sinning deliberately, is in great danger of never coming to the Truth. Therefore guard yourselves from this as from eternal death; for the man who always thinks that all is right and well with him, is in a dangerous and terrible state. If ye were to ask

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the reframes alone
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is a pastoral exhortation to humble fear and to pray for mercy, with the assurance that God will help — teaching found in Augustine himself and in every mainstream tradition, and it nowhere denies that the craving for mercy is itself prompted by prevenient grace, which is what Orange's canons 3–7 require. Indeed the same sermon says "to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own, or a striving after his own salvation," cutting against any claim that grace merely answers unaided human initiative. Nothing in the quote describes God as waiting on the human turn.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is pastoral exhortation to an already-believing hearer: fear God over unknown sins, beg mercy, count yourself a sinner, and God's grace will help you. Every mainstream tradition, Augustine and Orange included, urges the baptised to pray for mercy and promises help, without thereby teaching that God waits on an unaided human turn; Orange condemns denying that grace itself causes the prayer, and this sermon nowhere denies it — indeed it says elsewhere that "to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own" and that only God can make the temple holy. The quote also concerns ongoing sanctification, not the initium fidei that Canons 3-7 address.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is a pastoral exhortation — fear God over unknown sins, crave His mercy, count yourself a sinner, and you will surely be helped — which Augustine himself and every mainstream tradition preaches without teaching that grace waits upon an ungraced human initiative. Orange's Canon 4 condemns denying that the very will to be cleansed is itself infused by the Spirit; nothing here denies prevenient grace, and the same sermon says the opposite ("to the good man all things come from God without anything of his own, or a striving after his own salvation"). The hortatory "do this and then grace follows" is not the sharpened claim that God stands by awaiting the human turn.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

Withdrawn passages, 10 to a page, each with its challenges in full: 1–10 · 11–20

17 sermons read, fewer than the 20 a rate needs, so these are counts, not rates.

How these were counted

The part of each printed sermon read: teaching 17 — each part named with how many printed sermons it was read in.

Rates withheld. 17 sermons read, fewer than the 20 a rate needs, so these are counts, not rates
printed sermons
17
window
every printed sermon held here
read by
an AI model; details in About the study

We checked the sermons of Johannes Tauler against 115 rejected teachings, reading 17 whole sermons and the reframes of 17 sermons.

20 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.

The withdrawn passages come from 10 of the 17 sermons checked.

Read whole. 17 of the 17 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 18 passages looked like a match on that reading.

Read in their reframes. 17 of the 17 sermons in the basis above were read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 7 passages looked like a match on that reading.

Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.

The whole page · All churches