What was preached

All churches › Meister Eckhart › Teachings the church historically rejected

Meister Eckhart

What do the ▸ links mean?

Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →

0 published · 13 withdrawn, of 13 flagged in 6 sermons read

No passage is published and none is waiting to be checked: every passage that looked like a match was withdrawn on challenge.

Show the 13 withdrawn passages

Passages 1–10 of 13

Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.

SermonWhat was saidMatchesResult
The Attractive Power of Godpreached c. 1300 · #8473

Then, if she is willing, He pours the gift of His grace into the soul

paragraph 4, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

is to turn from sin and come to God in His heavenly kingdom, must be drawn by the heavenly Father with the might of His divine power. The Father also draws the Son who comes to help us with His grace, by stimulating our free will to turn away from, and hate sin, which has drawn us aside from God, and from the immutable goodness of the Godhead. Then, if she is willing, He pours the gift of His grace into the soul, which renounces all her misery and sin, and all her works become living. Now, this grace springs from the centre of Godhead and the Father’s heart, and flows perpetually, nor ever ceases, if the soul obeys His everlasting love. Therefore He saith in the prophets: “I have loved thee with an everlasting love, therefore with loving kindness have I drawn

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence follows immediately on the preacher's own statement that the Father draws us "by stimulating our free will to turn away from, and hate sin" — so the "willingness" the grace meets is itself produced by a prior divine drawing, not a human initiative God waits upon. That sequence of prevenient grace moving the will, followed by grace infused into the consenting soul, is ordinary Augustinian and Catholic teaching, and the sermon elsewhere insists in the preacher's own voice that "to turn from sin by one's own power and come to God is still much more impossible" and that the sinner "must be drawn by the heavenly Father." On that reading the sentence is cooperation with grace, not grace responding to an unaided human turn, which is what Orange condemned.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe cited clause is the second half of a sentence whose first half makes grace the initiator: the Son "comes to help us with His grace, by stimulating our free will to turn away from, and hate sin" — only then, "if she is willing, He pours the gift of His grace into the soul." That is the ordinary Catholic pattern of prevenient grace moving the will and further grace infused upon consent, which Orange itself teaches; it is not grace waiting upon an unaided human turn. The sermon elsewhere insists that "to turn from sin by one's own power and come to God is still much more impossible" and that the sinner "must be drawn by the heavenly Father," which forecloses the condemned reading.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnIn the sentence immediately preceding the quoted words, the willingness itself is produced by God: the Father draws "by stimulating our free will to turn away from, and hate sin," and the sermon insists repeatedly that "to turn from sin by one's own power and come to God is still much more impossible" and that whoever turns "must be drawn by the heavenly Father with the might of His divine power." Grace pouring into a soul whose willing has already been awakened by prevenient grace is the standard Augustinian and Catholic doctrine of cooperating grace — which Orange itself teaches — not grace that waits upon and responds to an unaided human turn.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
The Nearness of the Kingdompreached c. 1300 · #8474

His happiness increases and diminishes in proportion to the increase and diminution in his knowledge of this.

paragraph 2, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

nearness and presence of God. He is also near things of wood and stone, but they know it not. If a piece of wood became as aware of the nearness of God as an archangel is, the piece of wood would be as happy as an archangel. For this reason man is happier than the inanimate wood, because he knows and understands how God is near him. His happiness increases and diminishes in proportion to the increase and diminution in his knowledge of this. His happiness does not arise from this that God is near him, and in him, and that He possesses God; but from this, that he knows the nearness of God, and loves Him, and is aware that “the Kingdom of God is near.” So, when I think on God’s Kingdom, I am compelled to be silent because of its immensity, because God’s Kingdom is none

Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt

“Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

Words as recorded in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I, Adversus Haereses I.6.1-4; I.7.5, c. 180 · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is Eckhart's own, but it says only that a man's happiness rises and falls with his knowledge of God's nearness — a claim about degrees of beatitude, not about the origin of the soul or the nature of the human plight. The proposition requires a divine element originating above and alien to the material order, plus a predicament construed as ignorance rather than guilt; the quote asserts neither, and the surrounding sermon in fact has God equally near to wood and stone, which is the opposite of a matter-alien spark. Happiness proportioned to the knowledge of God is standard scholastic teaching on the visio Dei, so the sentence carries no Gnostic anthropology.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThat happiness or beatitude consists in the knowledge of God, and varies with the degree of that knowledge, is ordinary Augustinian and Thomistic teaching on the vision of God, and the sermon's surrounding frame is God's omnipresence to all creatures as Creator — wood, stone and archangel alike — not a divine spark originating above and alien to the material order. The quoted sentence also says nothing about guilt or about forgetting a heavenly origin; Eckhart immediately grounds happiness in knowing and loving God's nearness, not in recovered gnosis of the self's provenance. Silence about sin in a sermon on contemplative knowledge is not an assertion that the human predicament is ignorance rather than guilt.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence says a man's happiness rises and falls with his knowledge of God's nearness — which is standard scholastic teaching that beatitude consists in the knowledge and love of God, admitting of degrees (Aquinas on the visio Dei), and the very next sentence grounds it in knowing *and loving* God, not in recovering a hidden divine identity. The proposition requires a divine element of alien origin outside the material order whose predicament is forgetfulness rather than guilt; this sermon teaches the opposite dualism-wise, insisting God is "equally near in all creatures" and recognizable in each one, with creatures as nothing before God rather than a foreign prison. The quote therefore carries ordinary mystical-Thomistic beatitude, not a Gnostic anthropology.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
The Nearness of the Kingdompreached c. 1300 · #8474

In similar fashion our salvation depends upon our knowing and recognizing the Chief Good which is God Himself.

paragraph 2, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

In similar fashion our salvation depends upon our knowing and recognizing the Chief Good which is God Himself. I have a capacity in my soul for taking in God entirely. I am as sure as I live that nothing is so near to me as God. God is nearer to me than I am to myself; my existence depends on the nearness and presence of God. He is also near things of wood and stone, but they know it not. If a piece of wood became as aware of the nearness

3 teachings

  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt

    “Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

    Words as recorded in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I, Adversus Haereses I.6.1-4; I.7.5, c. 180 · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading

    read in the reframes alone

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThat salvation consists in knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good is ordinary Augustinian and Thomistic teaching — the summum bonum and the beatific vision, grounded in John 17:3 ("this is life eternal, that they might know thee") — and is held across the mainstream Western tradition without any Gnostic anthropology. The quoted sentence says nothing of a divine spark of supramundane origin, and the sermon insists God is "equally near in all creatures," including wood and stone, which cuts against the material-order dualism the proposition requires. Nor does the preacher anywhere contrast ignorance with guilt, so the distinguishing sharpening "rather than primarily as guilt" is not asserted here.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is asserted in the preacher's own voice, but it says only that salvation consists in knowing and recognising God as the Chief Good — the ordinary language of John 17:3 and of the mainstream beatific-vision tradition, in which blessedness is the knowledge and love of God. It makes no claim about a pre-existent divine spark that does not belong to the material order, and it nowhere displaces guilt as the human predicament; indeed the sermon elsewhere speaks of serving God in fear and love and of God leading "the righteous." Knowledge-as-salvation in this contemplative sense is taught without any Gnostic anthropology, so the classification cannot stand on this quote.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe preacher does assert the sentence in his own voice, but "our salvation depends upon our knowing and recognizing the Chief Good which is God Himself" is ordinary Christian teaching on the knowledge and love of God (John 17:3, "this is life eternal, that they might know thee"), taught across the mainstream contemplative and Augustinian traditions without any Gnostic anthropology. The condemned proposition is a composite claim about a divine element of supramundane origin alien to the material order, with ignorance of that origin as the predicament; this sermon asserts the opposite of its first half, insisting that the soul's being is wholly dependent ("my existence depends on the nearness and presence of God") and that God is "equally near in all creatures," including wood and stone. Nothing here denies guilt or posits a forgotten heavenly origin, so the quote cannot carry the proposition.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge

    “Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge.”

    Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Gospel of Truth, NHC I,3; Apocryphon of John, the conclusion; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

    withdrawn in each reading: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading

    read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings

    the challenges, in full

    Read in the whole sermon

    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe condemned proposition has three defining parts: salvation as awakening, recognition of one's *origin above*, and a *revealer* who conveys the saving knowledge. The quoted sentence carries none of these — it says salvation depends on knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good, with no claim that the soul is of heavenly origin and no revealer figure; the surrounding sermon grounds this knowledge in God's nearness to the creature and in effortful, grace-given growth, not in recovered pre-existent identity. Knowledge of God as the substance of beatitude is ordinary Christian teaching (John 17:3, the beatific vision tradition), so the quote cannot bear the Gnostic claim placed on it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence says salvation depends on knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good — which is ordinary mainstream teaching (John 17:3, "this is life eternal, that they might know thee"; the scholastic account of beatitude as the knowledge and enjoyment of God as summum bonum). The condemned proposition is sharper: it requires recognition of the soul's *origin above* and a *revealer who brings knowledge*, neither of which appears here; the sermon instead has God as Creator "near things of wood and stone," and tells the soul it "must forget itself and lose itself," not recover a heavenly origin. A sentence that fits the orthodox doctrine of beatitude does not evidence Gnostic awakening.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe preacher does speak in his own voice, but the sentence says only that salvation depends on knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good — which is ordinary Augustinian/Thomistic teaching on beatitude ("this is life eternal, that they might know thee," John 17:3), taught across mainstream Catholic and mystical tradition without any Gnostic content. The condemned proposition is a sharpening with two distinctive elements that are nowhere in the evidence or the sermon: recognition of the soul's pre-existent "origin above," and a revealer figure who brings saving gnosis. Here the knowledge is of God as highest good, God is described as Creator present in all creatures, and the soul is urged to lose itself in God rather than discover itself as divine in origin.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

    Read in the reframes alone

    Challenge 1: withdrawnEckhart does assert this in his own voice, but the sentence says only that salvation depends on knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good — which is ordinary Christian teaching on the knowledge and vision of God (John 17:3, "this is eternal life, that they may know thee"; the scholastic beatific vision Eckhart is working within, and which the sermon frames as God drawing near and teaching the soul). The condemned proposition is specific: awakening to one's own origin *above*, effected by a *revealer* who imparts knowledge. Neither the pre-existent heavenly origin of the soul nor a gnosis-bringing revealer figure appears anywhere in the sermon; the knowledge here is of God as Creator near to all creatures, not of a divine self to be recalled.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence — that salvation depends on knowing and recognizing the Chief Good which is God Himself — is ordinary mainstream teaching: John 17:3 ("this is life eternal, that they might know thee"), Augustine's summum bonum, and the scholastic account of beatitude as the knowledge and vision of God. The condemned Gnostic proposition is distinguished by two elements absent from the quote and from the sermon: recognition of the soul's *origin above* (a pre-existent divine spark), and a *revealer* who descends with saving knowledge. Eckhart instead grounds the nearness of God in creation and providence ("my existence depends on the nearness and presence of God"; God "near things of wood and stone"), and makes the knowing a matter of love and awareness of a God already present, not of waking to a foreign origin. A sentence that fits the orthodox reading does not evidence the Gnostic one.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is ordinary Christian teaching that beatitude consists in the knowledge of God as the highest good — John 17:3 ("this is life eternal, that they might know thee") and the scholastic/Thomist doctrine of the visio Dei, which Eckhart is plainly working within as a Dominican. Nothing in the quote or its context carries the two distinguishing marks of the condemned proposition: the soul's pre-existent origin above, and a revealer figure who imparts saving gnosis; instead Eckhart has God as Creator "near things of wood and stone," happiness arising from knowing *and loving* Him, and God graciously "endeavouring to dwell with man." A mainstream tradition teaches this sentence without teaching Gnostic awakening, so the classification cannot stand.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
  • Socinianism, suppressed by the Sejm of Poland-Lithuania, 1638: What human beings lack is not ability but knowledge

    “What human beings lack is not ability but knowledge: the way to eternal life is not discoverable by nature and must be revealed, and Christ is that revelation.”

    Words as recorded in The Racovian Catechism (Catechesis ecclesiarum quae in Regno Poloniae ... affirmant), On free will (Rees, 1818), 1605-1609 · Suppressed by a state, not condemned by a council · The Sejm (Diet) of Poland-Lithuania, 1638 · source: the file records no link for this document

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this

    read in the whole sermon

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe Racovian proposition is an anthropological claim about free will: human ability is unimpaired and what is missing is knowledge, which nature cannot discover and which Christ must reveal. Eckhart's sentence makes neither move — it says nothing about ability or the corruption of the will, and it locates the knowing not in a revealed doctrine from Christ but in the soul's inward awareness of God's nearness ("it is taught from within"). Saying that salvation consists in knowing God is the common language of the contemplative tradition and of John 17:3 ("this is life eternal, that they might know thee"), and carries none of the Socinian denial the classification puts on it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe condemned proposition is a claim about the will: that nothing is defective in human ability, only in human information, which must be supplied by revelation in Christ. The quoted sentence says only that salvation depends on knowing and recognizing God as the Chief Good — the ordinary beatific-vision claim that blessedness consists in the knowledge of God, taught by Aquinas and the whole contemplative tradition — and carries none of the contrast with ability. Indeed the sermon cuts the other way, saying the renouncement is "difficult" and that "God is always ready, but we are very unready," so the evidence will not bear the weight the classification puts on it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe proposition is a Socinian claim about human faculties — that fallen humanity's deficit is informational rather than volitional, so that what is needed is revelation of the way to life rather than repair of ability. The quoted sentence makes no claim about ability at all; it is a statement that beatitude consists in knowing and loving God as the Chief Good, which is standard mystical and scholastic teaching on the vision of God, and the sermon elsewhere insists the soul must be made "God-like" and that renouncement is difficult. Nothing here touches free will, nature's capacity to discover salvation, or Christ as revelation.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Withdrawn
withdrawn on challenge; why, for each teaching, is under its name
The Nearness of the Kingdompreached c. 1300 · #8474

God is always ready, but we are very unready. God is near us, but we are far from Him.

paragraph 8, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

commencement of it, and the renouncement of all things, is difficult. But when one attains to it, no life is easier nor more pleasant nor more lovable, since God is always endeavouring to dwell with man, and teach him in order to bring him to Himself. No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself. God is always ready, but we are very unready. God is near us, but we are far from Him. God is within, and we are without. God is friendly; we are estranged. The prophet saith, “God leadeth the righteous by a narrow path into a broad and wide place, that is into the true freedom of those who have become one spirit with God.” May God help us all to follow Him that He may bring us to Himself. Amen.

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn in each reading: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings
the challenges, in full

Read in the whole sermon

Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted lines say only that God is always present and willing while we are distracted and estranged — a commonplace of Augustinian and mainstream mystical teaching about divine omnipresence and human sinfulness, not a claim that grace waits upon and responds to a human initiative. The immediately preceding sentences in fact assert the reverse order of priority: "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man... No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself," placing the initiative wholly on God's side. Since the sentence can be, and historically is, taught without the semi-Pelagian position Orange II condemned, the classification cannot stand.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted lines are a devotional contrast between God's constant readiness and our sinful estrangement ("God is within, and we are without"), language straight out of Augustine's Confessions; they say nothing about grace being conferred in response to a prior human turn. The immediately preceding sentences assert the opposite order of causation — "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man... No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself" — which is divine prevenience, not God waiting on the creature. The evidence therefore cannot carry the semi-Pelagian proposition Orange condemned.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted lines say God is always ready and near while we are unready and far — that locates the obstacle in human resistance, not the first movement in the human will. The immediately preceding sentences run the opposite way ("No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself"; "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man... to bring him to Himself"), which is prevenient divine initiative, exactly what Orange affirms. Orange's canons condemn grace given as a response to an unaided human turn; nothing in this evidence carries that claim, and Augustine himself speaks of God's constant nearness against human estrangement.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

Read in the reframes alone

Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted lines are the preacher's own words, but they assert an asymmetry of readiness and nearness, not a causal order in which God withholds grace until a human turn. The immediately preceding sentences run the other way — "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man, and teach him in order to bring him to Himself" and "No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself" — which places the initiative and the longing on God's side, the opposite of the semi-Pelagian ordering Orange condemned. "God is always ready, but we are very unready" is a commonplace of mainstream spiritual theology about human obstruction of a grace already offered, and does not carry the claim that grace is a response to a prior human movement.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted lines are a lament about human estrangement set directly against an assertion of divine initiative: the two sentences immediately before them say "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man, and teach him in order to bring him to Himself" and "No man desires anything so eagerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself." Read in that sentence-flow, "God is always ready, but we are very unready" asserts God's constant prior nearness and our sinful unresponsiveness — it does not say that God waits on a human turn or that grace is given in answer to it, which is what Orange condemned. The sermon's closing petition ("May God help us all to follow Him that He may bring us to Himself") points the same way, and the whole is ordinary preaching on prevenient divine nearness.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentences are in the preacher's own voice, but they do not say that God waits for a human turn before grace acts. In the immediately preceding lines he insists the initiative is entirely God's — "God is always endeavouring to dwell with man, and teach him in order to bring him to Himself. No man desires anything so eagueerly as God desires to bring men to the knowledge of Himself" — so "God is always ready, but we are very unready... God is near us, but we are far from Him" is a lament over human estrangement and resistance, not a claim that grace is a response to human movement. Contrasting God's unceasing prior willingness with human unreadiness is ordinary Augustinian preaching and is in fact the reverse of the semi-Pelagian position Orange condemned.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
The Angel's Greetingpreached c. 1300 · #8475

Then the Son opened the tent of His everlasting glory and came forth from His high place to fetch His Bride, whom the Father had espoused to Him from all Eternity, back to that heaven from which she came.

paragraph 5, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

God created the soul after the image of His highest perfection. He issued forth from the treasure-house of the everlasting Fatherhood in which He had rested from all eternity. Then the Son opened the tent of His everlasting glory and came forth from His high place to fetch His Bride, whom the Father had espoused to Him from all Eternity, back to that heaven from which she came. Therefore He came forth rejoicing as a bridegroom and suffered the pangs of love. Then He returned to His secret chamber in the silence and stillness of the everlasting Fatherhood. As He came forth from the Highest, so He returned to the Highest with His Bride, and revealed to her the

Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and…

“Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Tripartite Tractate, NHC I,5; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence is the preacher's own narration, but what it narrates is the Son's coming forth from the Father to fetch his Bride and return with her — the standard exitus-reditus and bridal-mysticism picture of the soul created in God's image, issuing from God and returning to him, taught by Bernard, Bonaventure and Aquinas without any Gnostic cargo. It says nothing about a divine spark lodged in *some* human beings, nothing about that element being foreign to the material order (the immediately preceding lines in fact say God *created* the soul and infused his glory into it), and nothing about the human predicament being ignorance rather than guilt, which is half of the proposition as framed. The quote cannot carry the claim placed on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Isaiah 36:3)
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is standard bridal-mystical allegory in the preacher's own voice, but what it says is that the Son came forth as a bridegroom (Ps. 19:5, which he echoes in the next line) to bring His Bride — the soul or the Church — home to heaven. Mainstream Christian mysticism from Bernard onward teaches exactly this, grounding the soul's heavenly "whence" in its creation "after the image of His highest perfection," which the sermon states explicitly a line earlier: a creature made by God, not an uncreated spark alien to the material order. Nothing in the quote restricts this to "some human beings" — the sermon is emphatically universal ("God brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not") — and nothing recasts the human predicament as ignorance rather than guilt.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Isaiah 36:3)
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is conventional bridal mysticism — the Son coming forth to bring His Bride home to heaven — taught by Origen, Bernard and the whole Song of Songs tradition without any Gnostic anthropology. The sermon grounds the soul's heavenly origin in creation, not in a consubstantial divine spark: "God created the soul after the image of His highest perfection" and "He has created the human soul and infused His glory into it." The proposition further requires a divine element in only *some* humans and a predicament of ignorance rather than guilt; this preacher makes it universal and says explicitly that man's unawareness "is man's fault."
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Isaiah 36:3)
The Angel's Greetingpreached c. 1300 · #8475

God brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not, whether thou sleepest or wakest; God worketh His own will. That man is unaware of it, is man’s fault, for his taste is so spoilt by feeding on earthly things that he cannot relish God’s love.

paragraph 4, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

it flee up or down, the heaven rains its influence upon it, and stamps its impress upon it, and makes it fruitful, whether it be willing or not. Thus doth God with men: whoever thinketh to escape Him, flies into His bosom, for every corner is open to Him. God brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not, whether thou sleepest or wakest; God worketh His own will. That man is unaware of it, is man’s fault, for his taste is so spoilt by feeding on earthly things that he cannot relish God’s love. If we had love to God, we should relish God, and all His works; we should receive all things from God, and work the same works as He worketh.

Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt

“Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

Words as recorded in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I, Adversus Haereses I.6.1-4; I.7.5, c. 180 · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses (Against Heresies), Book I

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the whole sermon
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe proposition requires that the human plight be cast as ignorance or forgetfulness "rather than primarily as guilt," but the quoted sentence does the opposite: Eckhart says the man's unawareness "is man's fault," and traces it to an appetite "spoilt by feeding on earthly things" — culpable disordered desire, which is ordinary ascetic and Augustinian teaching. Nor does the quote posit an uncreated spark belonging above the material order; in this same sermon the preacher says God "has created the human soul and infused His glory into it." The evidence therefore does not carry the claim placed on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Genesis 27:21)
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe proposition requires a pre-cosmic divine element not belonging to the material order, plus a predicament construed as ignorance "rather than primarily as guilt." The quoted sentence does the opposite on the second point: it says man's unawareness "is man's fault," caused by a taste "spoilt by feeding on earthly things" — culpable disordered appetite, which is standard Augustinian language, not ignorance in place of guilt. On the first point the sermon elsewhere has God "created the human soul and infused His glory into it," i.e. a creature made in the image, not an uncreated spark from above.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Genesis 27:21)
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe proposition requires that the human predicament be cast as ignorance and forgetfulness *rather than primarily as guilt*, but the quoted sentence does the opposite: it says man's unawareness "is man's fault," locating culpability in man's appetite being "spoilt by feeding on earthly things." Naming unawareness as fault born of disordered desire is ordinary ascetic and Augustinian teaching about concupiscence dulling the soul's relish for God, not a Gnostic displacement of guilt by ignorance. The evidence therefore does not carry the contrastive claim that was put on it.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation (Genesis 27:21)
The Angel's Greetingpreached c. 1300 · #8475

When man humbles himself, God cannot restrain His mercy; He must come down and pour His grace into the humble man

paragraph 4, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

Again: If I am in a higher place and say to some one, “Come up hither,” that might be difficult for him. But if I say, “Sit down,” that would be easy. Thus God dealeth with us. When man humbles himself, God cannot restrain His mercy; He must come down and pour His grace into the humble man, and He gives Himself most of all, and all at once, to the least of all. It is essential to God to give, for His essence is His goodness and His goodness is His love. Love is the root of all joy and sorrow. Slavish fear of God is to be put away. The right fear is the fear of losing God. If the earth flee downward from heaven, it

Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it

“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.”

Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the reframes alone
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence is a rhetorical restatement of the commonplace of James 4:6 / 1 Peter 5:5 ("God gives grace to the humble"), and its point in context is God's condescension rather than human achievement — the preceding image is that climbing up is hard, so God says "sit down" and comes down Himself. Mainstream Augustinian teaching holds this sentence while also holding that the humility itself is grace-given; and the immediately following lines ("God brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not... whoever thinketh to escape Him, flies into His bosom; God worketh His own will") assert divine priority and inescapability, which is the contrary of grace awaiting a human turn. The evidence therefore does not establish the condemned sharpening.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is a rhetorical restatement of James 4:6 / 1 Peter 5:5 — "God resisteth the proud, and giveth grace to the humble" — which the Augustinian and Thomist mainstream teaches without any suggestion that humility originates in unaided free will; Aquinas holds both that grace is given to those disposed and that the disposing is itself God's moving. Eckhart says nothing here about the origin of the humbling, which is what Orange's canons address, and the surrounding sermon insists on the opposite of a waiting God: "God brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not," and the earth "cannot flee from heaven... whether it be willing or not." The emphasis of the quote falls on God's inability to withhold generosity, not on a human turn that grace then answers.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawn"God giveth grace to the humble" (1 Pet. 5:5; Jas. 4:6) is a commonplace that Augustine and the whole Western tradition teach without making grace the reward of unaided human initiative — the humility is itself understood as grace-wrought. The sentence's force here is God's unrestrainable condescension ("He must come down"), not divine waiting, and the immediately following lines say the opposite of the condemned proposition: God "brings forth His Son in thee, whether thou likest it or not," and whoever tries to flee Him "flies into His bosom." On that reading the preacher is not asserting that grace merely responds to a prior human turn.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
True Hearingpreached c. 1300 · #8476

If a man could get free of these, he would dwell in eternity, and in the spirit, and in solitude, and in the desert, and there would hear the everlasting Word.

paragraph 1, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

confesseth Me and feareth Me, shall have eternal life. Whoso will hear the wisdom of the Father must dwell deep, and abide at home, and be at unity with himself. Three things hinder us from hearing the everlasting Word. The first is fleshliness, the second is distraction, the third is the illusion of time. If a man could get free of these, he would dwell in eternity, and in the spirit, and in solitude, and in the desert, and there would hear the everlasting Word. Our Lord saith, “No man can hear My word nor my teaching without renouncing himself.” All that the Eternal Father teaches and reveals is His being, His nature, and His Godhead, which He manifests to us in His Son, and teaches us that we are also His Son.

Docetism, rejected by the early church: Salvation is release from the material condition rather than the redemption of it

“Salvation is release from the material condition rather than the redemption of it.”

Words as recorded in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, Adversus Haereses III.18-22; V.14, c. 180 · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Ignatius of Antioch, Letters to the Trallians and Smyrnaeans, c. 107-110 · source: Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses

Withdrawn
withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this
read in the reframes alone
the challenges, in full
Challenge 1: withdrawnThe sentence is about the conditions for hearing God's word — freedom from fleshliness, distraction and the illusion of time — not about what salvation consists in. Detachment, solitude and "the desert" as preparation for hearing God is the ordinary language of the mainstream ascetic and contemplative tradition (the desert fathers, monastic renunciation), and it is taught without any claim that matter is to be escaped rather than redeemed. The sermon itself affirms God manifesting Himself in His Son and working in us, which cuts against reading it as a release-from-matter soteriology.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is spoken in the preacher's own voice, but it is about the conditions for *hearing the everlasting Word* — he has just named fleshliness, distraction and the illusion of time as the three things that "hinder us from hearing" — not about what salvation consists in. Nothing in it says the body or the material order is escaped rather than redeemed; stated as detachment for the sake of contemplation, it is the common teaching of the monastic and desert tradition, which held the resurrection of the flesh at the same time. To read a sentence about recollection and silence as the Gnostic claim that salvation is release from the material condition is to load onto it a soteriology it never states.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence names three hindrances to *hearing the everlasting Word* — fleshliness, distraction, and the illusion of time — and says freedom from them would let a man dwell "in solitude, and in the desert" and hear. That is the stock language of the mainstream contemplative and monastic tradition (fleshliness in the Pauline sense of disordered sarx, not materiality as such), and it is taught without any claim that salvation is escape from matter; the quote says nothing about salvation at all, and nothing setting release from the material against its redemption. The surrounding sermon likewise frames all this as renunciation of self and of created goods, a commonplace ascetic theme, not a Valentinian account of the body or the cosmos.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
True Hearingpreached c. 1300 · #8476

There is a somewhat in the soul that is, as it were, a blood-relative of God. It is one, it has nothing in common with nothing, nor is it like nothingness, nothing. All that is created is nothing, all far from and foreign to the soul.

paragraph 5, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

he might receive from God. When for God’s sake he gave up God, God still remained with him, since God’s essence is Himself, not any impression or reception of Himself. He who does so is a true man to whom no grief may happen, any more than it happens to the Divine Being. There is a somewhat in the soul that is, as it were, a blood-relative of God. It is one, it has nothing in common with nothing, nor is it like nothingness, nothing. All that is created is nothing, all far from and foreign to the soul. Could I but find myself one instant in that sphere of pure existence, I should regard myself as little as a worm.

2 teachings

  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and…

    “Some human beings carry within them a divine element — a spark, seed or pneuma — that originates above and does not belong to the material order; the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt.”

    Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Tripartite Tractate, NHC I,5; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the rejected teaching says something different from what the match assumed; the words also fit an orthodox reading

    read in the whole sermon

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe proposition as given is a Gnostic elect anthropology: a divine element in *some* human beings, originating above and alien to the material order, with the predicament reframed as ignorance and forgetfulness of that origin rather than guilt. The preacher asserts, in his own voice, only that there is "somewhat in the soul" — the human soul as such, not a pneumatic class — that is "as it were" kin to God, which is the Augustinian imago Dei / scintilla animae of mainstream Latin theology (cf. Acts 17:28-29); the sermon's diagnosis is fleshliness, distraction and failure to renounce self, and its remedy is conformity to God's will, not recollection of a forgotten heavenly origin. The sentence is therefore narrower and other than the condemned proposition, however much the surrounding language about created things being "nothing" presses hard.
    Why: the rejected teaching says something different from what the match assumed · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe preacher does assert this in his own voice, but the sentence — that there is "as it were" something in the soul akin to God, and that created things are "nothing" beside it — is the ordinary Christian doctrine of the imago Dei and the soul's kinship with God (Gen 1:26, Acts 17:29, Augustine's mens as image of the Trinity), joined to standard apophatic devaluation of creatures. The condemned proposition is narrower: it holds that only SOME human beings carry a divine element that originated above and fell into matter, with ignorance of that origin as the predicament; this sermon predicates its "somewhat" of the soul as such, with no elect class, and diagnoses fleshliness, distraction and the illusion of time, prescribing self-renunciation rather than recollection of a pre-cosmic origin. A sentence that fits the imago Dei cannot be made to evidence Gnostic pneumatic anthropology.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is the mainstream Augustinian-scholastic doctrine of the imago Dei / scintilla animae: a capacity in the soul, "as it were" a kinsman of God, by which the soul is capable of God and is nothing apart from Him — taught in the Catholic mystical and scholastic tradition (Augustine, Bonaventure's apex mentis) without any Gnostic dualism. The condemned proposition is narrower in the very respects absent here: it restricts the divine element to SOME human beings (the pneumatic elect) over against others, makes it alien to the material order by origin, and reframes the human predicament as ignorance of that origin rather than guilt. This sermon speaks of the soul as such, not an elect class, and locates the human problem in fleshliness, distraction and self-will, with renunciation and abiding in God's will as the remedy — not forgotten celestial origin.
    Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
  • Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: What is saved is what came from above; the material order is not itself redeemed

    “What is saved is what came from above; the material order is not itself redeemed, and in most of these systems is dissolved or left behind rather than restored.”

    Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Gospel of Truth, NHC I,3; Apocryphon of John, the conclusion; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

    withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this

    read in the reframes alone

    the challenges, in full
    Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is a contemplative claim about creatures' nothingness in comparison with God and the soul's detachment from them — the commonplace "omnis creatura est nihil" of Augustinian and Thomist participation metaphysics and of mainstream mystical theology. It says nothing whatever about what is saved, about a divine element descended from above, or about the eschatological fate of the material order being dissolved rather than restored. The surrounding sermon is about renunciation and abiding in God's will, not about matter being excluded from redemption, so the soteriological proposition is simply not carried by this evidence.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted line is a comparative statement of creaturely nothingness over against God's being — standard Christian apophatic and ascetic language used here to urge detachment, immediately alongside the soul's uncreated "somewhat." It makes no claim about what is saved or whether the material order is redeemed, and the sermon elsewhere has angels joyfully serving creation and a man receiving the world back from God. The soteriological proposition is read into the sentence rather than asserted by it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
    Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted sentence is a metaphysical claim about the nothingness of creatures relative to God and to the "somewhat in the soul" — the standard apophatic/detachment language of the Rhineland mystical tradition, echoing the Augustinian point that creatures have no being of their own. It says nothing about what is saved or about the fate of the material order, which is the whole substance of the proposition; the preacher's sermon is about renunciation and conformity to God's will, not cosmology or redemption. Nothing in this sermon has him asserting that only a higher element is saved while the material creation is dissolved or left behind, so the evidence will not carry the soteriological claim placed on it.
    Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Withdrawn
withdrawn on challenge; why, for each teaching, is under its name
True Hearingpreached c. 1300 · #8476

All that the Eternal Father teaches and reveals is His being, His nature, and His Godhead, which He manifests to us in His Son, and teaches us that we are also His Son.

paragraph 1, in the edition on ccel.org A printed sermon, not a recording — linked at the edition it was printed in, with its paragraph named; there is no moment.

the printed paragraph around the quote · printed edition

second is distraction, the third is the illusion of time. If a man could get free of these, he would dwell in eternity, and in the spirit, and in solitude, and in the desert, and there would hear the everlasting Word. Our Lord saith, “No man can hear My word nor my teaching without renouncing himself.” All that the Eternal Father teaches and reveals is His being, His nature, and His Godhead, which He manifests to us in His Son, and teaches us that we are also His Son.

Gnosticism, rejected by the early church: Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge

“Salvation is described as awakening: the recognition of one's origin above, effected by a revealer who brings knowledge.”

Words as recorded in The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library), Gospel of Truth, NHC I,3; Apocryphon of John, the conclusion; Gospel of Philip, NHC II,3, 2nd-3rd century · Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling) · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180 · source: The Nag Hammadi codices (Coptic Gnostic Library)

Withdrawn
withdrawn in each reading: the quote doesn't actually say this; the words also fit an orthodox reading
read in the whole sermon and in the reframes alone — the same passage, flagged by both readings
the challenges, in full

Read in the whole sermon

Challenge 1: withdrawnThe proposition's distinctive content — salvation as an awakening to a pre-existent origin "above," accomplished by a revealer who imparts saving knowledge — is not what the quoted sentence says. Eckhart is asserting in his own voice, but what he asserts is that the Father reveals His own being in His Son and makes us sons: the ordinary Christian doctrine of revelation in Christ and divine filiation/adoption (John 1:18, Romans 8:15-17, Galatians 4:4-7), taught as theosis across mainstream traditions. Nothing in the quote or its surrounding sermon — which is about renunciation, detachment and hearing the eternal Word — frames salvation as recollection of a heavenly origin or makes gnosis the saving instrument.
Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence is Eckhart teaching that the Father reveals His being in the Son and makes us sons in the Son — adoptive divine filiation and Christ as the revealer of the Father, which is ordinary Christian teaching (Gal. 4, Rom. 8, John 1:18) and a staple of Rhineland mysticism. The condemned proposition is a sharpening: salvation as *awakening* to a pre-existent origin *above*, accomplished by saving knowledge. Nothing in the quote speaks of the soul's heavenly origin or of gnosis as the mechanism of salvation; the surrounding sermon frames the way to God as renunciation of self and abiding in God's will, not as recollection of where the soul came from.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence says the Father reveals His own being in His Son and teaches us that we are also His Son — that is ordinary Christian teaching on Christ as the revealer of the Father (John 1:18, 14:9) joined to divine filiation/adoption (Rom. 8:14-17, Gal. 4:4-7), a theme mainstream Catholic, patristic and Reformed traditions teach without any Gnostic content. The condemned proposition requires salvation as an awakening to a pre-existent origin above, recovered by saving gnosis; nothing in this quote or its surrounding paragraph speaks of a heavenly origin recalled or of knowledge as the mechanism of rescue — the sermon's stated path is renunciation of self and abiding in God's will, not escape by enlightenment.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

Read in the reframes alone

Challenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted sentence says that the Father makes His own being known in His Son and makes us sons — the ordinary Johannine and Pauline grammar of revelation and adoption (John 1:18; Rom 8:15-17; Gal 4:6), taught by every mainstream tradition without any claim that knowledge is the saving instrument. The condemned proposition requires salvation to BE awakening to a pre-existent origin above, and the quote contains neither awakening nor origin above; it only contains "reveals" and "teaches." The sermon's own soteriology is explicitly renunciative — "no man can hear My word... without renouncing himself," "must be dead to himself" — which cuts against, rather than toward, salvation by gnosis.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 2: withdrawnThe sentence says the Father reveals His own being and nature in His Son and makes us sons — that is the ordinary Christian doctrine of revelation in Christ and adoptive filiation (John 1:12, Romans 8:14-17, 2 Peter 1:4), taught across Catholic and Reformed traditions. The condemned proposition requires salvation to consist in awakening to a pre-existent origin above, delivered by a revealer whose gnosis is itself the saving thing; nothing in the quote speaks of a heavenly origin, of awakening, or of knowledge as the mechanism of rescue. The surrounding sermon frames the goal as renunciation of self and abiding in God's will, not recognition of a divine spark's provenance, so the Gnostic reading is not the available one.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation
Challenge 3: withdrawnThe sentence is Eckhart's own, but what it asserts is that the Father is made known in the Son and that we are made sons in Him — the ordinary Christian doctrines of revelation in Christ (John 1:18, Matt 11:27) and adoptive sonship (Rom 8:14-17, Gal 4:4-7), taught across mainstream traditions. Nothing in it describes salvation as awakening to a pre-existent origin above, and the sermon's remedy throughout is renunciation of self and abiding in God's will, not saving gnosis. The quote therefore fits an orthodox reading without carrying the Gnostic proposition.
Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation

Withdrawn passages, 10 to a page, each with its challenges in full: 1–10 · 11–13

6 sermons read, fewer than the 20 a rate needs, so these are counts, not rates.

How these were counted

The part of each printed sermon read: teaching 6 — each part named with how many printed sermons it was read in.

Rates withheld. 6 sermons read, fewer than the 20 a rate needs, so these are counts, not rates
printed sermons
6
window
every printed sermon held here
read by
an AI model; details in About the study

We checked the sermons of Meister Eckhart against 115 rejected teachings, reading 6 whole sermons and the reframes of 6 sermons.

13 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.

The withdrawn passages come from 6 of the 6 sermons checked.

Read whole. 6 of the 6 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 11 passages looked like a match on that reading.

Read in their reframes. 6 of the 6 sermons in the basis above were read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 8 passages looked like a match on that reading.

Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.

The whole page · All churches