All churches › Phillips Brooks › Teachings the church historically rejected
Phillips Brooks
What do the ▸ links mean?
Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →
0 published · 2 withdrawn, of 2 flagged in 2 sermons read
Sermons: 2 read whole · 1 read in their reframes
No passage is published and none is waiting to be checked: every passage that looked like a match was withdrawn on challenge.
Show the 2 withdrawn passages
Each quote is the sermon’s words, said in the preacher’s own voice.
| Sermon | What was said | Matches | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Pride of Lifepreached c. 1859 · #8615 |
| Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: the first movement toward God, the beginning of faith or bare willingness to believe (initium fidei, and the credulitatis affectus)…“But the first movement toward God, the beginning of faith or bare willingness to believe (initium fidei, and the credulitatis affectus), can arise from the human being, and God's grace then meets, enables and completes it.” Words as recorded in John Cassian, Conlationes (Conferences), Conference 13 (Abbot Chaeremon, on the Protection of God), Conference 13, chapters 8-13, c. 426-429 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: John Cassian, Conlationes (Conferences), Conference 13 (Abbot Chaeremon, on the Protection of God) | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe quoted clause sits inside the sentence "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us, that He asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness" — its force is that God, not the man, does the converting, and a few lines earlier the preacher says the needed change "can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost" and cites "Except a man be born again." The condemned proposition requires that the initium fidei originate in the human being with grace following; this sentence asserts the reverse ordering, with human submission as response to a help already willing and at work. Language of yielding to God's prior grace is ordinary in mainstream traditions and does not evidence semi-Pelagianism. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe quoted words sit inside the clause "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us, that He asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness" — "nothing but" minimizes the human part within a sentence whose actor is God, rather than locating the first movement of faith in man. Moments earlier the preacher states the change "can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost," cites "Except a man be born again," and calls humility's source "the coming of God into us," fixing grace as prior. The condemned proposition requires that the initium fidei originate in the human being with grace following to complete it; this evidence asserts the reverse order, and submission to a prior, willing grace is ordinary teaching in every mainstream tradition. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe quoted clause is the second half of a sentence whose first half says the opposite of the proposition: "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us, that He asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness." A few lines earlier the preacher says the change is "so hard that it can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost," and he grounds it in "Except a man be born again." "Nothing but submission" is a minimizing of the human part — a yielding to grace already at work — not a claim that the initium fidei arises from the human being and is then met by grace; the condemned proposition locates the first movement in man, which this sentence expressly denies. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
| The Pride of Lifepreached c. 1859 · #8615 |
| Semi-Pelagianism, rejected at the Second Council of Orange, 529: God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it“On this account God is described as awaiting the human turn, and grace as responding to it.” Words as recorded in The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition, Canons 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 529 · Condemned by a council · Second Council of Orange (Concilium Arausicanum II), 529 · source: The Canons of the Second Council of Orange, with the concluding definition | Withdrawn withdrawn on 3 of 3 challenges: the words also fit an orthodox reading; the quote doesn't actually say this read in the whole sermon the challenges, in fullChallenge 1: withdrawnThe clause is Brooks's gloss on John 14:23 ("If any man love me he will keep my words... we will come unto him"), and naming love and obedience as the condition of that indwelling is ordinary exposition of the verse in every mainstream tradition. He surrounds it with the opposite of a semi-Pelagian claim: the change "can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost," and immediately after the quoted words he says "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us, that He asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness." Nothing here makes grace the response to an unaided human turn, which is what Orange condemns. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 2: withdrawnThe clause is Brooks expounding the dominical saying he has just quoted ("If any man love me he will keep my words... we will come unto him"), naming the condition the verse itself names; it says nothing about God waiting on an unaided human initiative or grace arriving only in response to it. The immediately following sentence cuts the other way — "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us, that He asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness" — as does his earlier insistence that the needed change "can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost." The quote therefore does not carry the Orange-condemned claim put on it. Why: the quote doesn't actually say this · Scripture: not a Bible quotation Challenge 3: withdrawnThe clause is the preacher's gloss on the verse he has just quoted ("If any man love me he will keep my words... we will come unto him"), restating Christ's own stated condition for the indwelling; every mainstream tradition teaches that promise without teaching that grace waits on unaided human initiative. The surrounding sentences cut directly against the condemned proposition: he says the change is "so hard that it can be brought about by no other than the Almighty Holy Ghost," that "such a conversion is a work that God has undertaken to do for us," and that God "asks of us nothing but submission to His willing helpfulness." On any fair reading the love and obedience are fruit of a prior divine work, not the human turn that God awaits. Why: the words also fit an orthodox reading · Scripture: not a Bible quotation |
2 sermons read, fewer than the 20 a rate needs, so these are counts, not rates.
How these were counted
The part of each printed sermon read: teaching 2 — each part named with how many printed sermons it was read in.
- printed sermons
- 2
- window
- every printed sermon held here
- read by
- an AI model; details in About the study
We checked the sermons of Phillips Brooks against 115 rejected teachings, reading 2 whole sermons and the reframes of 1 sermon.
2 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.
The withdrawn passages come from 1 of the 2 sermons checked.
Read whole. 2 of the 2 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 2 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Read in their reframes. 1 of the 2 sermons in the basis above was read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 0 passages looked like a match on that reading.
Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.