What was preached

All churches › About the study › Annunciation Catholic Church

Annunciation Catholic Church

Altamonte Springs, FL Roman Catholic (Diocese of Orlando)

Reach, not attendance 13.3K YouTube subscribers · Oct 2026

All 51 sermons published Aug 2025 – Aug 2026 measured.

At a glance

Sermons read
51

31% ±6

kept to the apostles’ terms What this means

Kept to the apostles’ terms means the sermon taught or mentioned a part of the gospel in the terms the apostles used for it. The rest it reframed: carried the part in its own words instead, speaking of sin as “your mistakes”, say (an illustration, not a quote from this church). Reframed does not mean wrong, and it does not mean missing.

Counted out of every time a gospel part came up across the 51 sermons read: kept 106 of 344, reframed 238. The ±6 is how far the figure moves when those sermons are drawn again at random (the middle 95% of 1,000 redraws).

It is not a grade, and churches are not sorted by it. Churches that preach a set passage each week touch more parts, and so have more chances to reframe one.

The yardstick is how the apostles preached each part, chiefly in the sermons of Acts and in 1 Corinthians 15. The site sets the sermon beside it, and you judge.

This church’s reframes, each with what it put in the verse’s place →

Scripture read aloud or quoted
0.7%of the teaching words of 48 sermons; a floor, counted in five translations
How these were counted

What was collected

measured in the window Every one of the 51 recordings this church published inside the window 2025-08-22 to 2026-08-21 carries a stored classification: 51 of 51, with none outstanding. 51 of those 51 have a transcript in this corpus.

What every figure is counted over

The part of each recording read: teaching 51 — each part named with how many recordings it was read in.

recordings
51
window
2025-08-24 → 2026-08-16
read by
an AI model; details in About the study

Where this church is, and the sources

where
Altamonte Springs, FL
tradition
Roman Catholic (Diocese of Orlando)
size
size not established — not in the Hartford Institute megachurch database (checked 2026-11-04); no sourced attendance figure was found — not in the Hartford megachurch database (read 2026-11-04; all 1,670 entries searched by name, city and web domain); Hartford excludes Catholic parishes by stated policy; no attendance figure on the parish site (home, about/history, staff, Mass schedule, register, financial and council pages, and the 2026-11-01 bulletin PDF read); its history says the 1979 combined parishes "included 3,000 families", which is not weekly attendance; no press or third-party figure found.
reach
13,300 YouTube subscribers (shown on cards as 13.3K), measured 2026-10-14 — reach, not attendance: accounts subscribed to the channel, anywhere and for any reason, not people in a congregation; it places this church in no group and orders nothing — channel measured: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTCYqYkzsySAVHmx0nGtGjQ — YouTube's displayed count, which it rounds to about three significant figures; read with yt-dlp from the channel recorded as this church's source
channel recorded as the source
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTCYqYkzsySAVHmx0nGtGjQ — the source of every transcript measured here, so a figure on this page can be checked against the recordings it was computed from
the church's own site
https://annunciationorlando.org

What the sermons taught

11 parts over 51 sermons

taughtmentioned in passingonly in a repeated formulareframedabsent

  • Who God is — creator, holy taught 4 · mentioned in passing 1 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 44 · absent 2
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught40.074
    mentioned in passing10.018
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed440.812
    absent20.037
    present in49 of 5196%

    Read in full →

  • Human sin and need taught 9 · mentioned in passing 4 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 35 · absent 3
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught90.166
    mentioned in passing40.074
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed350.646
    absent30.055
    present in48 of 5194%

    Read in full →

  • Jesus' identity as Christ, Son of God taught 8 · mentioned in passing 22 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 16 · absent 5
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught80.148
    mentioned in passing220.406
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed160.295
    absent50.092
    present in46 of 5190%

    Read in full →

  • His death for sins taught 2 · mentioned in passing 7 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 13 · absent 29
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught20.037
    mentioned in passing70.129
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed130.240
    absent290.535
    present in22 of 5143%

    Read in full →

  • His burial taught 0 · mentioned in passing 1 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 2 · absent 48
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught00.000
    mentioned in passing10.018
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed20.037
    absent480.885
    present in3 of 516%

    Read in full →

  • His resurrection taught 5 · mentioned in passing 5 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 5 · absent 36
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught50.092
    mentioned in passing50.092
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed50.092
    absent360.664
    present in15 of 5129%

    Read in full →

  • Witnesses to it taught 2 · mentioned in passing 0 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 11 · absent 38
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught20.037
    mentioned in passing00.000
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed110.203
    absent380.701
    present in13 of 5126%

    Read in full →

  • Call to repent and believe taught 2 · mentioned in passing 0 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 44 · absent 5
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught20.037
    mentioned in passing00.000
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed440.812
    absent50.092
    present in46 of 5190%

    Read in full →

  • Forgiveness / justification taught 2 · mentioned in passing 7 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 25 · absent 17
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught20.037
    mentioned in passing70.129
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed250.461
    absent170.314
    present in34 of 5167%

    Read in full →

  • New life, the Spirit, discipleship taught 19 · mentioned in passing 1 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 28 · absent 3
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught190.350
    mentioned in passing10.018
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed280.516
    absent30.055
    present in48 of 5194%

    Read in full →

  • Return and judgment taught 2 · mentioned in passing 3 · only in a repeated formula 0 · reframed 15 · absent 31
    treatmentnper 1k words
    taught20.037
    mentioned in passing30.055
    only in a repeated formula00.000
    reframed150.277
    absent310.572
    present in20 of 5139%

    Read in full →

Not covered by these 11 parts: sacraments · church order · why?

Scripture read aloud

0.7% of the teaching words, over 48 sermons

Scripture read aloud or quoted: 0.7% of the teaching words, over 48 sermons — a floor: only five translations are on file.

357 of 53,950 teaching words, Aug 2025 – Aug 2026. Half of these sermons fall between 0.0% and 0.9%; the middle sermon is at 0.2%.

How the share was counted

A word counts when it is inside 7 or more words in a row that match a Bible verse in one of five translations on file (ASV, BSB, KJV, LEB, NHEB). Readings in other translations, such as the ESV, NIV, NRSV or NASB, are partly missed, so this is a floor. It counts Scripture’s words said aloud — read, quoted, or used as a greeting or a prayer — and not whether a sermon is about a text: a passage explained in the preacher’s own words is not in it. The same rule marks a reframe’s words that are a verse.

Not in this figure: 3 recordings whose teaching span is under 300 words.

The apostolic core

three measures over 51 sermons, each beside the reference

51 sermons · 22 Aug 2025 – 21 Aug 2026

Said Jesus died14 of 51
Said he rose7 of 51
Called hearers to repent or believe2 of 51
All three: died, rose, and a call or an offer2 of 51

a call: urges the listeners to repent, believe or come to Jesusan offer, no call: states the promise (“whoever believes is forgiven”) without urging

Where the meaning shifted

238 reframes in 50 of 51 sermons

A reframe carries a gospel part in the sermon’s own words. Each bar counts what those words put in place of the verse’s, part by part.

  • pointed somewhere else: the sermon aims the verse’s words at a different thing
  • narrowed: the same thing as the verse, made smaller
  • within: stays inside what the verse says
  • two readings disagree: a second reading gave another label; both answers are shown

Most recent: Jesus' identity as Christ, Son of God, against Acts 2:36 / John 20:31

  1. pointed somewhere elseboth Lord and Christ → he can heal her

    2026-08-16 · “20th Sunday in Ordinary Time - August 16, 2026 - 10am” #7347 ▸ 20:38

    transcript 20:04–21:20 · Whisper

    And when that didn't dissuade her persistence, it seems to exhibit another very human behavior. He insulted her. This might have discouraged other people from their persistence, but not her. She is the most faith-filled in her border crossing. Because she'll take the insults, but she won't take no for an answer. She is fighting for her child's life, and she has the faith in Jesus, knowing that he can heal her. It seems that some people just don't belong. They might be annoying. They might not fit in. They might not be the right sort of person. So why didn't the Canaanite woman belong? Three significant reasons. She's a woman. She's a Canaanite, a Gentile. And she's annoying.

How this was read
withinthe object stays inside what the anchor verse supports
narroweda narrower object than the verse names
pointed somewhere else(redirected) a different object from the verse's

‘Within’ and ‘narrowed’ labels here have all had a second reading: 53 confirmed, 10 where two readings disagreed.

Receipts: ▸ opens the recording at the moment the words begin; a note follows only when there is no single exact moment. Transcript sources: Whisper = our Whisper transcription of the audio; auto captions = YouTube’s automatic captions; channel captions = captions the channel uploaded to YouTube. How receipts work →

Teachings the church historically rejected

0 published · 3 withdrawn, of 3 flagged in 50 sermons read
How these were counted

We checked the sermons of Annunciation Catholic Church against 115 rejected teachings, reading 12 whole sermons and the reframes of 50 sermons.

3 passages looked like a match. Each was then challenged three separate times, and is published only if it held every time.

No passage is published and none is waiting to be checked: every passage that looked like a match was withdrawn on challenge.

Show the 3 withdrawn passages →

Every passage with each of its challenges written out in full is on this church’s claims page.

Against its own statement

One box per historically rejected teaching its statement was read against, or a passage preached here was flagged on: whether the preaching said it, and what the statement says.

Counted over the 50 sermons read (12 read whole; for the other 38, only the passages where a part of the gospel was reframed).

Also checked, not found in the 50 sermons read

  • Condemned by a church ruling: In the Noetian form the Father is therefore the one who was born and suffered
    Sabellianism · A presbytery at Smyrna, c. 200
    1 passage came close and was withdrawn. Its statement of faith (also its tradition’s): not yet read against this.
  • Condemned by a council: the Son is the Father and the Father the Son
    Sabellianism · A synod at Rome under Bishop Dionysius, c. 262
    1 passage came close and was withdrawn. Its statement of faith (also its tradition’s): not yet read against this.
  • Rejected by the early church (no single council ruling): the human predicament is described as ignorance and forgetfulness of this origin rather than primarily as guilt
    Gnosticism · opposed in Irenaeus of Lyons, Adversus Haereses, c. 180
    1 passage came close and was withdrawn. Its statement of faith (also its tradition’s): not yet read against this.

Whether any sermon spoke against its own statement is not yet measured: a denies is not yet put to the three challenges, so no such sentence is printed from one.

What the preaching rests on

The Bible: 58% of the reasons · 1.2 stories per 1,000 words · in 36 sermons

Wherever the preacher gave a reason for what they said, we noted what it pointed to. 36 sermons, Aug 2025 – Aug 2026, 44,258 words of teaching: 324 reasons, 7.3 per 1,000 words. Read on: teaching 35, unsegmented 1.

Reasons given, by what they pointed to
foundper 1,000 wordssharein sermons
The Bible1874.258%36/36
… the passage named aloud501.115%
… no passage named1373.142%
A Christian teacher or writer130.34%7/36
Something God said to the preacher00.00%0/36
Something that happened400.912%17/36
Outside knowledge: a study, a figure, history50.12%5/36
Not shown: 4 kinds, 79 of the 324 reasons (counted in the shares)
  • a creed or the church’s teaching (19 of 30 matched), a writing presented as prophetic (14 of 30 matched): checked against a second, blind reading by another model (Fable), which put too few under the same kind to show it for any church; 24 of 30 needed.
  • everyday wisdom and culture, something else: two readings of the same sermons differed too much to compare one church with another.
  • Views the preacher quoted in order to describe or answer them: 1, not counted as reasons.

Stories told to picture a point: 1.2 per 1,000 words (52). A second reading counts about as many but not the same ones, so none is quoted.

How steady these figures are

676 sermons were read a second time, from 132 sources (78 churches, 23 reference figures and 31 historical preachers): three from each of 102, and from 1 to 29 from each of the other 30. The two readings found the same reason 70% of the time, and put it under the same kind 98% of the time.

For 9 of this church’s sermons read twice, the Bible’s share moved 7.2 points.

A kind is shown only where its change between readings is small beside the spread between churches. Two clear it narrowly (change, then spread, per 1,000 words): something that happened 0.26 against 0.36; outside knowledge: a study, a figure, history 0.14 against 0.27.

The whole table.

The words

The earliest in the year, one per sermon.

The Bible 3 examples
  • Especially when he says. Before we have done anything. That you are very good.

    2025-08-31 · “22nd Sunday in Ordinary Time - August 31, 2025 - 10am” #7396 ▸ 30:23

    transcript 29:52–31:00 · Whisper

    Freely given and freely received. And it is that love and only that love which defines us. That love which gives us our value. Our worth. Our dignity. So why is it that we spend so much time. Concerned about the opinions of others. Fixated on what they see or what they say. When in reality we should be more concerned about what God sees. And what he says. Especially when he says. Before we have done anything. That you are very good. But we can err in the other extreme as well. Thinking that we are too much like God. And not enough like the creature that we are. Pride isn't about acknowledging our God given gifts. But rather pride is always comparing those gifts with the gifts of everybody else. Or thinking that we have a possession over those gifts. That I am the origin. And I am the beneficiary of those gifts.

  • When he reveals himself to the Israelites while they are in Egypt, he opens himself and welcomes them in to become his firstborn son. He gives them food and freedom. He gives them water and refuge. And in response, they turn against him. They grumble.

    2025-09-15 · “The Exaltation of the Cross - September 14, 2025 - 10am” #7395 ▸ 38:44

    transcript 38:10–39:34 · Whisper

    child. For this time, he didn't choose safety. He did not choose the hardening of his heart, he allowed his heart to remain soft, to remain supple, to remain susceptible to the sword of sorrow that would pierce it, recognizing that in a relationship, happiness and pain so often come together. You can't choose the one without also accepting the other. God too, in a certain sense, takes a risk. When he reveals himself to the Israelites while they are in Egypt, he opens himself and welcomes them in to become his firstborn son. He gives them food and freedom. He gives them water and refuge. And in response, they turn against him. They grumble. They call into question his power and his goodness. When God opens up, when he reveals himself, he too becomes susceptible. He becomes vulnerable to their doubt and their derision. And we see the result of that in our first reading. Now, if you were a God made in my image and likeness, I would see that as a just and opportune end to a regrettable relationship,

  • the prophet Amos just chastises the people of the Northern Kingdom of Israel for their refusal to recognize that they too are a pilgrim people

    2025-09-28 · “26th Sunday in Ordinary Time - September 28, 2025 - 10am” #7393 ▸ 32:55

    transcript 32:24–33:36 · Whisper

    And lastly, a pilgrim is one who realizes at every moment that they are a foreigner in a foreign land and yet seeks to find that home, that place of rest, that home which is not defined by bricks and mortar, but that place where I belong, where I am fully alive, where I am seen and heard, known and loved, and have no more need for masks or walls with which to defend myself. In our first reading, the prophet Amos just chastises the people of the Northern Kingdom of Israel for their refusal to recognize that they too are a pilgrim people who are set upon a journey, but rather have chosen a life that is sedentary and comfortable, seeking after satisfaction rather than sanctification, until the day when God himself will set them on a pilgrimage and he will send them into exile. The second characteristic that is highlighted during a pilgrim year is mercy. Now our English word mercy comes from the Latin word miséricordia,

A Christian teacher or writer 3 examples
  • Pope Francis was once asked by a young boy, Father, what was God doing before he made the world?

    2025-10-12 · “28th Sunday in Ordinary Time - October 12, 2025 - 10am” #7391 ▸ 27:21

    transcript 26:49–27:59 · Whisper

    He wasn't bored and in need of entertainment. He wasn't weak or lazy and in need of minions or some sort of servants. From all time, God has always been and will always be perfect and perfectly happy in himself. He needs nothing. Nor are we the consequence of some chance or chaotic cosmic collision. But we have been willed into being. Pope Francis was once asked by a young boy, Father, what was God doing before he made the world? Taken a little bit aback by such a deep and difficult question from one so young, the Pope took a time to reflect quietly and then responded. What God was doing before he made the world was that he was loving. Because God is love. From all of eternity, God has been loving. But not in some generic abstract way, but in a very specific, concrete way.

  • One of the most insightful explanations of this indwelling comes from a theologian, N.T. Wright. Who begins where our gospel begins today. With the temple.

    2025-11-16 · “33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time - November 16, 2025 - 10am” #7386 ▸ 31:55

    transcript 31:22–32:46 · Whisper

    Warning that the end is near. But when will the end come? No one knows. But frankly, it's the wrong question. And we can't waste our time worrying about it. Because timing isn't the point. Rather, our focus needs to be on the Christ. Who dwells within each of us. No matter what we have done or what we have failed to do. One of the most insightful explanations of this indwelling comes from a theologian, N.T. Wright. Who begins where our gospel begins today. With the temple. The Old Testament tells us that on the day of dedication of Solomon's temple, the glory of Yahweh, in the form of fire and a cloud from the heaven, descended and filled the temple. Just as it has come once, filled the tent of meeting in the desert. This became the assurance of the abiding and localized divine presence of Yahweh and made the temple,

  • He simply responded, you're not done. You're only now ready to begin.

    2026-02-01 · “4th Sunday in Ordinary Time - February 1, 2026 - 10am” #7375 ▸ 27:54

    transcript 27:19–28:28 · Whisper

    After many years at seminary, I walked into my spiritual director's office and told him that I had had it. I was leaving. My bags were packed. I was heading home. I was going to find a new path. When I looked up, I noticed that, well, he was laughing at me. Exacerbated, I said, did you hear what I just said? Why are you laughing? It's over. It's gone. I'm done. He said no. He simply responded, you're not done. You're only now ready to begin. You see, it wasn't in strengths, but in weakness. It wasn't in the heights, but in the depths. It was there lying flat on his back. All of his earthly achievements strewn around him on the ground on the road to Damascus. That Paul was finally ready to begin. Humility. It is a virtue that our first reading describes as characterizing the faithful remnants of God's people.

Something God said to the preacher: none found in these 36 sermons.

Something that happened 3 examples
  • I was fortunate to just have returned from a pilgrimage to Rome and the surrounding cities with my previous parish assignment

    2025-09-28 · “26th Sunday in Ordinary Time - September 28, 2025 - 10am” #7393 ▸ 29:55

    transcript 29:23–30:32 · Whisper

    we are presently celebrating a Jubilee year, which the Universal Church recognizes every 25 years. Customarily during such a Jubilee, two activities are highlighted. The first is pilgrimage. Now a pilgrimage is not a tour or a vacation, but rather it's a reflection of our journey through life, our journey through faith, in a very distilled or concentrated form. I was fortunate to just have returned from a pilgrimage to Rome and the surrounding cities with my previous parish assignment. And during the many miles that we walked each day, I had the opportunity to reflect on those characteristics that are meant to define us as a pilgrim people journeying through this earthly sojourn. A pilgrim is one who walks with a purpose, who walks with meaning, who has a destination in mind and doesn't simply become an aimless wanderer through life.

  • We've seen how it has caused so many to draw farther away from the Lord, perhaps even in rebelliousness towards him.

    2025-10-26 · “30th Sunday in Ordinary Time - October 26, 2025 - 10am” #7389 ▸ 34:45

    transcript 34:13–35:09 · Whisper

    hearts are broken open that he can enter in and only once we are crushed that he can form us anew. brought low to our knees, maybe those are only the times in which we can or do reach up to touch the sky. So much of our faith is paradoxical. So much of our faith is counterintuitive to our fallen human reason. And so pain as God's megaphone is a terrible instrument and it is a tremendous gamble. We've seen how it has caused so many to draw farther away from the Lord, perhaps even in rebelliousness towards him. But this risk must be worth it, because it must bring about the best way, or perhaps the only way, that draws him close to us and us close to him.

  • They shared with me their search for truth, their search for something substantial, something into which they could sink their teeth, that could provide a reasonable response to those deep questions that resided in the depths of their hearts.

    2025-11-30 · “1st Sunday of Advent - 10am Mass - November 30, 2025” #7384 ▸ 29:17

    transcript 28:40–30:04 · Whisper

    A couple of weeks ago, immediately after a Sunday Mass, and while still dressed in my vestments, I was stopped just outside the front doors by a group of six young men, probably in their early to mid-20s. They told me that this was the first time that they had ever been in a Catholic church. Forgoing the typical courtesies of introduction and welcome, I simply stated to them, I simply asked them, well, why is it that you are here today? They shared with me their search for truth, their search for something substantial, something into which they could sink their teeth, that could provide a reasonable response to those deep questions that resided in the depths of their hearts. They also shared with me this belief that someone, somewhere, could offer an alternative narrative to the one that they had been hearing everywhere else. That search, that hunger, brought those men to this parish on that day. But similar stories have been leading record-breaking numbers of young adults,

Outside knowledge: a study, a figure, history 3 examples
  • Because humility comes from the word hummus. Which means dirt or dust or earth.

    2025-08-31 · “22nd Sunday in Ordinary Time - August 31, 2025 - 10am” #7396 ▸ 27:16

    transcript 26:43–27:52 · Whisper

    Why is it that we think that these two concepts, humility and perfection, are so starkly opposed to one another? We have a tendency to ascribe this characteristic of humility to the one who constantly and consistently denigrates themselves. Who beats themselves up and tears themselves down. The one who has an overall just poor opinion of themselves. And maybe there is some warrant to this. Because humility comes from the word hummus. Which means dirt or dust or earth. And it seems like it would be appropriate for the person who is the lowest or the meanest. And so if somebody is perfect in every way, it would be very difficult to act in a way that is so contrary to their daily experience. But this isn't real humility. In fact, this is a kind of pride or maybe it is a cry for attention.

  • our English word mercy comes from the Latin word miséricordia, which comprises two other words, misere, which is misery or poverty, and cordia, which is heart

    2025-09-28 · “26th Sunday in Ordinary Time - September 28, 2025 - 10am” #7393 ▸ 33:31

    transcript 32:59–34:13 · Whisper

    the people of the Northern Kingdom of Israel for their refusal to recognize that they too are a pilgrim people who are set upon a journey, but rather have chosen a life that is sedentary and comfortable, seeking after satisfaction rather than sanctification, until the day when God himself will set them on a pilgrimage and he will send them into exile. The second characteristic that is highlighted during a pilgrim year is mercy. Now our English word mercy comes from the Latin word miséricordia, which comprises two other words, misere, which is misery or poverty, and cordia, which is heart. And so mercy or miséricordia happens when one person takes their loving heart and encounters the poverty or the misery of another. For the ancient Jews, the year of Jubilee, they experienced mercy with the forgiveness of their debt, with setting them free from the slavery of those taxes which they couldn't pay. Also in the restoration of their land,

  • and even from self-confidence. A word that means, with faith in myself.

    2026-02-01 · “4th Sunday in Ordinary Time - February 1, 2026 - 10am” #7375 ▸ 31:31

    transcript 31:00–32:09 · Whisper

    And we stand there vulnerable and exposed. That's what happened to me in seminary. Or humiliation happens when we fall from the heights of vain glory, to which we had climbed by our own strength and success. That's what happened to St. Paul on his way to Damascus. But humility occurs that when in that moment of humiliation, we turn away from ourself. We turn away from self-assertion, from self-aggrandizement, from self-reliance, and even from self-confidence. A word that means, with faith in myself. Instead, in those moments, we turn to the Lord. And like a child who wants to reach to the heights, but only recognizes that it can achieve such an end, when it is lifted up by his Father. I want to learn how to be like St. Paul. To boast. But boast not in my strengths, but in my weaknesses. To boast in my poverty, in my mourning, in my hungering, and in my thirst.

Beside what it says about authority

What the preaching pointed to

Of 324 reasons: the Bible 187; a Christian teacher or writer 13; something God said to the preacher 0; something that happened 40; outside knowledge: a study, a figure, history 5.

36 sermons, Aug 2025 – Aug 2026

What the church states and its tradition records

This church adopts No statement of faith; its tradition and statement are the same document.

Roman Catholic: Scripture, tradition and the teaching office of the church

"receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety, and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament" together with "the said traditions, as well those appertaining to faith as to morals" (Trent IV, 1546); "it is not from Sacred Scripture alone that the Church draws her certainty about everything which has been revealed" (Dei Verbum 9, 1965).

Council of Trent, Session IV, Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures; Decree concerning the Edition and Use of the Sacred Books

What the file records

The canon includes the deuterocanonical books (Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, 1-2 Maccabees, and the Greek portions of Esther and Daniel), fixed by name at Trent Session IV with an anathema attached to rejecting them.

Council of Trent, Session IV, Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures

What the file records

The Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex cathedra as supreme pastor and teacher defining a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, is preserved from error; such definitions are described as irreformable of themselves and not by the consent of the Church.

Pastor Aeternus ch. 4

A rule of faith says what judges doctrine. These counts say what the preaching pointed to. They are different questions, and this page does not say whether they agree.

What this does not measure
  • A church’s final rule of faith. Quoting a theologian or telling a story is not a rule of faith.
  • Time. A ten-minute story is one story.
  • Claims made with no reason given. A sermon that gives few reasons shows a low count; nothing here marks a sentence as unsupported.

How this was measured and its limits

what these figures cannot tell you, and how the matches were found
What this measurement cannot do

The limits worded identically on every page are stated once, in full, on About the study; every one of them still applies to every figure here. Those most pages share are named below with a link, because each applies here. The ones in full below are worded about this measurement in particular.

A statement exists for these churches and has not yet been read by the classifier. — applies here →

One classification pass. — applies here →

Some components carry runs made under a different rubric or over a different text. — applies here →

medium These churches adopt their tradition's own confession or formulary wholesale, so the tradition and the statement are ONE DOCUMENT. The relation reads "same document" and no gap is printed between them, because there is nothing between them to be a gap.

About the tradition and the statement side by side

How the matches were found and challenged

Sermons are read in two ways. Some are read whole. Others are read only in the passages where the sermon reframed a part of the gospel, which is far less text. Either way, each historically rejected teaching is asked about: does the sermon say it, say the opposite, or not touch it? A passage where it seems to say it looked like a match. That passage is then put to three independent challenges, each asked to show it does not say it, and a single withdrawal sinks it. The claims table says on each row how its sermon was read. When both readings flagged the same words for the same teaching and decided alike, it is one passage and one row, naming both readings.

how it was readsermons readteachings read againstpassages flaggedpublishedwaitingwithdrawn
read from the WHOLE transcript121151001
read from the reframe quotes alone, a narrower basis501152002

Read whole. 12 of the 51 sermons in the basis above were read whole against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 1 passage looked like a match on that reading.

Read in their reframes. 50 of the 51 sermons in the basis above were read only in the passages where it reframed a part of the gospel against 115 historically rejected teachings, and 2 passages looked like a match on that reading.

Each of those lines counts only the sermons read that way, and the teachings they were read against, not every sermon in the basis.

The reframes, against historically rejected teachings

A separate pass from the one above. It takes only the verbatim quotes that produced a reframed treatment and routes those through the condemned propositions, so it answers a narrower question: not what the sermon addressed, but whether what it substituted lands on something a council rejected.

Read this narrowly. Only these axes have been run on this track: anthropology, authority, god and christ, soteriology — every other axis is unmeasured here, not clear. Each claim counted under matched, with the sermon's words and every pass, is in this church's refutation layer, focused track.